Pertanian & Lingkungan editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Limits to Measurement: Rethinking the Role of Monitoring in Environmental Governance
Marc Tadaki's paper identifies four limits—scarce resources, ontological ambiguity, epistemological narrowing, and decision-making logics—that undermine the promise of measurement in environmental governance, using New Zealand's freshwater monitoring as a case study.
Marc Tadaki· Environment and Planning E Nature and Space· 2024· DOI 10.1177/25148486241248012
The core problem
The paper explores the role of measurement in securing sustainable and just environmental governance. It examines New Zealand's ambitious initiative to monitor and improve its freshwaters, which exemplifies a global trend toward science-driven environmental governance reform. The author argues that while measurement is often seen as a key tool for achieving environmental goals, it is subject to inherent limits that can undermine its effectiveness. By identifying these limits, the paper aims to reveal the costs of current approaches and suggest alternatives that are more robust and realistic.
Innovation
The paper employs a qualitative case study approach, focusing on New Zealand's freshwater monitoring initiative. Through document analysis and possibly interviews (though not explicitly stated), the author identifies four 'limits' to measurement: scarce resources, ontological ambiguity, epistemological narrowing, and decision-making logics. The analysis is situated within the broader context of environmental governance and science and technology studies (STS), drawing on theoretical perspectives to critique the assumption that more data leads to better environmental outcomes.
Introduction
The paper explores the role of measurement in securing sustainable and just environmental governance. It examines New Zealand's ambitious initiative to monitor and improve its freshwaters, which exemplifies a global trend toward science-driven environmental governance reform. The author argues that while measurement is often seen as a key tool for achieving environmental goals, it is subject to inherent limits that can undermine its effectiveness. By identifying these limits, the paper aims to reveal the costs of current approaches and suggest alternatives that are more robust and realistic.
Why it matters
The paper discusses the implications of these limits for environmental governance. It argues that ignoring these limits leads to unrealistic expectations and potential failures in governance reforms. Instead, the author proposes a new modus operandi for environmental science that acknowledges these limits and adapts accordingly. This approach would be more practically ambitious, as it would account for the complexities of real-world governance, and less vulnerable to failure. The discussion also highlights the need for reflexive and inclusive practices that incorporate diverse knowledge systems and values, moving beyond a narrow focus on measurement to embrace a more nuanced understanding of environmental governance.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…