Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2022
Misinformation in Experimental Political Science
The American Political Science Association cautions against using misinformation in human-subjects research. Barnfield argues that misinformation harms both ethics and inference, and proposes a simple remedy: tell the truth.
M. Barnfield· Perspectives on Politics· 2022· DOI 10.1017/S1537592722003115
The core problem
The American Political Science Association (APSA) recently issued a caution against the use of misinformation—defined as giving research participants false information about the state of the world—in research with human subjects. This recommendation reflects a growing recognition, as experimental research itself grows in prevalence in political science, that deceptive practices pose ethical problems. The article asks what is wrong with misinformation in particular. The author argues that while the question certainly has an ethical dimension, misinformation is also detrimental to inference: it moves researchers away from effectively answering questions about the political world. A straightforward, intuitive solution to this twofold problem is proposed: tell the truth.
Innovation
This is a conceptual and normative analysis rather than an empirical study. The author examines the practice of using misinformation in experimental political science, drawing on the APSA's recent caution and the broader literature on deception in human-subjects research. The argument proceeds by identifying two distinct problems with misinformation: an ethical problem and an inferential problem. The proposed solution—telling the truth—is presented as a straightforward and intuitive remedy that addresses both dimensions simultaneously.
Introduction
The American Political Science Association (APSA) recently issued a caution against the use of misinformation—defined as giving research participants false information about the state of the world—in research with human subjects. This recommendation reflects a growing recognition, as experimental research itself grows in prevalence in political science, that deceptive practices pose ethical problems. The article asks what is wrong with misinformation in particular. The author argues that while the question certainly has an ethical dimension, misinformation is also detrimental to inference: it moves researchers away from effectively answering questions about the political world. A straightforward, intuitive solution to this twofold problem is proposed: tell the truth.
Why it matters
The author argues that the twofold problem of misinformation—ethical and inferential—admits of a simple solution: tell the truth. By avoiding the provision of false information to research participants, researchers can simultaneously uphold ethical standards and preserve the inferential validity of their experiments. The argument implies that truth-telling should be the default practice in experimental political science, and that the growing prevalence of experimental research makes this commitment increasingly important. The article thus contributes to ongoing debates about research ethics and methodological rigor in political science.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…