Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Pendidikan editorial

Open AccessOA2022

Models as Epistemic Artifacts for Scientific Reasoning in Science Education Research

This digest examines the argument that empirical science education research inconsistently treats models as both representations and tools, and proposes an artifactual approach that frames models as epistemic tools constructed to answer questions, thereby clarifying access to unobservable systems.
Marvin Rost; T. Knuuttila· Education sciences· 2022· DOI 10.3390/educsci12040276

The core problem

Models are central to scientific reasoning and science education, particularly in contexts where the primary objects of study are unobservable. Empirical science education researchers often draw on philosophical arguments about models and modeling. This paper examines exemplary empirical studies through the lens of philosophy of science. The authors observe that these studies tend to identify modeling with representation while simultaneously approaching models as tools. They argue that this dual approach is inconsistent and propose considering models as epistemic artifacts instead. The artifactual approach is claimed to offer epistemic benefits, making access to unobservable target systems less mysterious by treating models not as more or less accurate representations but as tools constructed to answer theoretical and empirical questions. This question-oriented approach is said to contribute to a more consistent theoretical understanding of modeling and interpretation of empirical research results.

Innovation

The paper employs a philosophical analysis of exemplary empirical studies in science education research. The authors adopt a philosophy of science perspective to scrutinize how these studies conceptualize models and modeling. They identify a recurring pattern: studies often conflate modeling with representation while also treating models as tools. The methodology involves critical examination of this dual approach and the proposal of an alternative framework—models as epistemic artifacts. The analysis is conceptual, drawing on arguments from philosophy of science to assess the consistency and implications of the theoretical assumptions underlying empirical research. No new empirical data are collected; rather, the study synthesizes and critiques existing approaches.
Introduction
Models are central to scientific reasoning and science education, particularly in contexts where the primary objects of study are unobservable. Empirical science education researchers often draw on philosophical arguments about models and modeling. This paper examines exemplary empirical studies through the lens of philosophy of science. The authors observe that these studies tend to identify modeling with representation while simultaneously approaching models as tools. They argue that this dual approach is inconsistent and propose considering models as epistemic artifacts instead. The artifactual approach is claimed to offer epistemic benefits, making access to unobservable target systems less mysterious by treating models not as more or less accurate representations but as tools constructed to answer theoretical and empirical questions. This question-oriented approach is said to contribute to a more consistent theoretical understanding of modeling and interpretation of empirical research results.

Why it matters

The discussion centers on the implications of adopting an artifactual approach to models in science education research. The authors contend that treating models as epistemic artifacts resolves the inconsistency of the dual approach. Instead of evaluating models primarily by their accuracy as representations, the artifactual view emphasizes their role as tools constructed to address specific questions. This shift has several consequences: it clarifies how models provide access to unobservable systems (since models are not required to mirror reality but to serve inquiry), it aligns better with actual modeling practices in science, and it offers a more coherent framework for interpreting empirical studies. The authors suggest that this question-oriented approach can lead to more consistent theoretical foundations for research on models and modeling in science education. The paper concludes by advocating for the artifactual perspective as a means to advance both theoretical understanding and empirical research in the field.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…