Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2025
Murder by Treachery in Islamic and Indonesian Criminal Law
This study analyzes qatl al-ghīlah (murder by treachery) in Islamic criminal law and argues for its integration into Indonesian criminal law reform, highlighting cases like the Ferdy Sambo and KM 50 incidents.
M. Irfan; M. Rosyid; M. Faiz· Al-Risalah· 2025· DOI 10.30631/alrisalah.v25i2.2039
The core problem
The study addresses the concept of *qatl al-ghīlah* (murder by treachery) in Islamic criminal law and its relevance to reforming Indonesia's national criminal law. *Qatl al-ghīlah* is a distinct category of murder with characteristics that differentiate it from other types of homicide. From the perspective of *fiqh jināyah* (Islamic criminal jurisprudence), this crime is classified as murder whose punishment is enforced through *qiṣāṣ* (retaliation) and cannot be waived even if the victim's family forgives. The authors argue that this issue is increasingly relevant given several cases in Indonesia, such as the murder of Affan Kurniawan by a police officer, the Ferdy Sambo case, the KM 50 incident, and other cases demonstrating weak protection of public security. Previous studies have rarely connected the normative concept of *qatl al-ghīlah* with practical issues in Indonesian positive criminal law, creating a gap in understanding how treachery-based murder should be legally qualified. This study aims to fill that gap by providing a conceptual foundation for discussing a special category of murder based on exceptions, thereby integrating Islamic values of justice into the Indonesian criminal law system.
Innovation
The study employs a qualitative, normative approach through literature review and case analysis. It examines classical Islamic legal sources on *qatl al-ghīlah* and analyzes relevant Indonesian cases to draw connections between the normative concept and practical legal qualification. The methodology focuses on doctrinal analysis of *fiqh jināyah* and comparative legal analysis with Indonesian positive criminal law.
Introduction
The study addresses the concept of *qatl al-ghīlah* (murder by treachery) in Islamic criminal law and its relevance to reforming Indonesia's national criminal law. *Qatl al-ghīlah* is a distinct category of murder with characteristics that differentiate it from other types of homicide. From the perspective of *fiqh jināyah* (Islamic criminal jurisprudence), this crime is classified as murder whose punishment is enforced through *qiṣāṣ* (retaliation) and cannot be waived even if the victim's family forgives. The authors argue that this issue is increasingly relevant given several cases in Indonesia, such as the murder of Affan Kurniawan by a police officer, the Ferdy Sambo case, the KM 50 incident, and other cases demonstrating weak protection of public security. Previous studies have rarely connected the normative concept of *qatl al-ghīlah* with practical issues in Indonesian positive criminal law, creating a gap in understanding how treachery-based murder should be legally qualified. This study aims to fill that gap by providing a conceptual foundation for discussing a special category of murder based on exceptions, thereby integrating Islamic values of justice into the Indonesian criminal law system.
Why it matters
The discussion elaborates on the normative concept of *qatl al-ghīlah* and its potential application in Indonesia. In Islamic law, *qatl al-ghīlah* is considered a form of murder that is particularly heinous because it involves treachery and premeditation, and thus the punishment cannot be pardoned by the victim's family. The authors argue that Indonesian criminal law currently lacks a specific category for treachery-based murder, leading to inconsistent legal qualification. By drawing on the Islamic concept, the study proposes a legal framework that distinguishes *qatl al-ghīlah* as a special category of murder with corresponding penalties. The analysis also addresses potential challenges in integrating Islamic law into the secular national legal system, emphasizing the importance of contextualization and alignment with human rights principles. The study concludes that adopting the concept of *qatl al-ghīlah* would not only fill a legal gap but also strengthen the justice system by acknowledging the severity of treacherous murders.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…