Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2025
New political science analysis of the renewed push for preventive health: 'Can it be any different this time around?'
This study applies political science analysis to preventive health efforts via Integrated Care Systems in England, identifying barriers like short-termism and financial pressures, and enablers such as systems leadership and institutionalising prevention. It argues that a paradigm shift requires long-term political support and local collaboration.
Paul Cairney; John Boswell; H. Mahmood; A. Blissยท Social Science & Medicine (1967)ยท 2025ยท DOI 10.1016/j.socscimed.2025.118568
The core problem
The idea that 'prevention is better than cure' is often treated as self-evident in health policymaking: who would not want to shift resources from mitigating acute problems to their prevention? However, there is always a gap between rhetorical commitments and practice, producing cycles of enthusiasm then limited progress. If prevention returns to the top of the agenda, how can this time be different? To answer that question, we applied new political science analysis to recent efforts to promote prevention via Integrated Care Systems (ICSs) in England. We theorise persistent barriers to prevention caused by limited: clarity regarding its meaning in practice, congruity with routine policy delivery, and capacity to sustain major changes.
Innovation
We engaged with local and national health and care policy practitioners to explore how these barriers have manifested in practice. We convened seven focus groups (2024) containing sixty participants, then used qualitative thematic analysis to categorise challenges and responses.
Introduction
The idea that 'prevention is better than cure' is often treated as self-evident in health policymaking: who would not want to shift resources from mitigating acute problems to their prevention? However, there is always a gap between rhetorical commitments and practice, producing cycles of enthusiasm then limited progress. If prevention returns to the top of the agenda, how can this time be different? To answer that question, we applied new political science analysis to recent efforts to promote prevention via Integrated Care Systems (ICSs) in England. We theorise persistent barriers to prevention caused by limited: clarity regarding its meaning in practice, congruity with routine policy delivery, and capacity to sustain major changes.
Why it matters
Paradigm shift towards prevention requires long-term repeated efforts to bolster political support for change and support local collaboration to build and maintain systemic capacity. Political science-driven analysis helps to frame and support this process. The study highlights that overcoming persistent barriers requires addressing limited clarity, congruity, and capacity, and leveraging enablers to embed prevention into routine policy delivery.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ