Humaniora editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Obstacles to Moral Articulation in Interreligious Engagement
Nicholas Adams argues that the imperative to articulate deepest moral commitments in interreligious dialogue distorts those commitments and excludes important voices, drawing on Hegel, Schelling, Adorno, and tragic figures Cordelia and Antigone.
Nicholas Adams· International Journal of Philosophy and Theology· 2023· DOI 10.1080/21692327.2024.2308123
The core problem
The paper addresses a well-known problem in interreligious engagement in European institutions: the tendency to exclude contributions that do not conform to certain European expectations. Adams diagnoses problems produced not only by the problem itself but also by certain solutions to it, and proposes an alternative approach. Chief among these problems is the imperative that members of traditions articulate their deepest moral commitments in order to secure a common moral ground. This imperative has the unintended but drastic effect of excluding important voices in dialogue. The originality of the argument lies in using aesthetic theory in German philosophy to inform a critique of attempts to make morality central to interreligious engagement.
Innovation
The paper employs a theoretical framework drawn from Hegel, Schelling, and Adorno as interpreted by Alasdair MacIntyre, Charles Taylor, and Andrew Bowie. It also draws on literary figures—Cordelia from Shakespeare's *King Lear* and Antigone from Sophocles' *Antigone*—to argue that forced articulation distorts its objects. The method is thus a philosophical critique that combines German aesthetic theory with tragic drama to illuminate the dynamics of interreligious dialogue.
Introduction
The paper addresses a well-known problem in interreligious engagement in European institutions: the tendency to exclude contributions that do not conform to certain European expectations. Adams diagnoses problems produced not only by the problem itself but also by certain solutions to it, and proposes an alternative approach. Chief among these problems is the imperative that members of traditions articulate their deepest moral commitments in order to secure a common moral ground. This imperative has the unintended but drastic effect of excluding important voices in dialogue. The originality of the argument lies in using aesthetic theory in German philosophy to inform a critique of attempts to make morality central to interreligious engagement.
Why it matters
Adams argues that the solution to the exclusion problem is not to demand more articulation but to recognize the limits of articulation and the value of silence and indirect communication. Drawing on Adorno's critique of identity thinking and the aesthetic theory of Schelling and Hegel, the paper suggests that moral commitments are often embedded in practices and forms of life that resist explicit articulation. The alternative approach proposed in outline involves attending to the aesthetic and performative dimensions of interreligious engagement, allowing for modes of moral expression that do not conform to the imperative of articulation. This approach would better accommodate the diversity of traditions and avoid the exclusionary effects of forced articulation.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…