Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2024

On Being and Becoming Human Through Accompaniment and Telos: Ontological Convergences Between Christian Anthropology and the Science of Human Development

This digest synthesizes the argument that Christian anthropology and relational developmental systems (RDS) science share ontological commitments to embodiment, holism, relationality, and telos. The authors contend that these convergences enable mutually beneficial religion–science collaboration to foster thriving and support social justice.
Richard M. Lerner; P. E. King; Elizabeth M. Dowling; Edmond P. Bowers· Journal of psychology and theology· 2024· DOI 10.1177/00916471241300154

The core problem

The article opens by identifying a surprising convergence between two seemingly disparate magisteria: Christian anthropology and contemporary developmental science, particularly the dynamic, relational developmental systems (RDS) approach. Both traditions, the authors argue, place relationality—especially mutually beneficial, nurturing relationships between the individual and others—at the center of human development and thriving. The central thesis is that these ontological convergences are not merely academic but provide a foundation for enacting mutually beneficial collaborations between religion and science. Such collaborations, if realized, could promote thriving lives for individuals and support social justice movements. The authors frame the discussion around several shared concepts: embodiment, holism, the specificity of mutually influential individual ⇔ context coactions, relationality, and telos. The introduction sets the stage for a detailed exploration of each concept, demonstrating how Christian anthropology and RDS-based developmental science, despite different vocabularies and historical trajectories, converge on a relational ontology of the human person.

Innovation

This is a conceptual and comparative analysis rather than an empirical study. The authors employ a method of ontological comparison, systematically examining key concepts from Christian anthropology and RDS-based developmental science to identify points of convergence. The methodology involves:

- **Conceptual mapping**: Identifying core ontological categories (embodiment, holism, relationality, telos, etc.) in both traditions.
- **Comparative analysis**: Demonstrating how each tradition understands these categories and where they align.
- **Synthesis**: Arguing that the convergences provide a basis for religion–science collaboration.

The authors draw on magisterial teachings and contemporary developmental theory, particularly the RDS metatheory, which emphasizes dynamic, relational processes and the coaction of individual and context. The analysis is framed within a relational developmental systems paradigm, which posits that human development is characterized by mutually influential individual ⇔ context relations (often denoted as individual ⇔ context coactions). The authors do not present new empirical data; instead, they build a theoretical argument for ontological convergence. The method is thus hermeneutic and integrative, aiming to bridge disciplinary divides by highlighting shared foundational assumptions about human nature and development.

Introduction
The article opens by identifying a surprising convergence between two seemingly disparate magisteria: Christian anthropology and contemporary developmental science, particularly the dynamic, relational developmental systems (RDS) approach. Both traditions, the authors argue, place relationality—especially mutually beneficial, nurturing relationships between the individual and others—at the center of human development and thriving. The central thesis is that these ontological convergences are not merely academic but provide a foundation for enacting mutually beneficial collaborations between religion and science. Such collaborations, if realized, could promote thriving lives for individuals and support social justice movements. The authors frame the discussion around several shared concepts: embodiment, holism, the specificity of mutually influential individual ⇔ context coactions, relationality, and telos. The introduction sets the stage for a detailed exploration of each concept, demonstrating how Christian anthropology and RDS-based developmental science, despite different vocabularies and historical trajectories, converge on a relational ontology of the human person.

Why it matters

In the discussion, the authors elaborate on the implications of these ontological convergences. They argue that because Christian anthropology and RDS-based developmental science share fundamental assumptions about human nature—embodiment, holism, relationality, and telos—they can engage in mutually beneficial collaboration. Such collaboration could take several forms:

- **Joint research**: Designing studies that incorporate both scientific and theological perspectives on relational development.
- **Practical interventions**: Developing programs that foster nurturing relationships and aim at thriving, informed by both traditions.
- **Social justice advocacy**: Leveraging the shared commitment to relationality and telos to promote social justice movements that support the thriving of all individuals.

The authors emphasize that this collaboration is not about conflating religion and science but about recognizing their distinct yet convergent ontologies. They suggest that the concept of the reciprocating self—a person who both receives and gives in relationships—serves as a bridge between the Christian telos of living with and for others and the RDS telos of thriving through mutually beneficial relationships. The discussion also addresses potential challenges, such as differing epistemological frameworks, but concludes that the ontological convergences provide a robust foundation for dialogue and joint action. The authors call for further interdisciplinary work that takes both traditions seriously and explores how their shared insights can be harnessed to promote human flourishing and social justice.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…