Humaniora editorial
Open AccessOA2024
On Cultural Sociology of Cultural Representations: A Symposium Poised Between History and Sociology
This paper introduces a symposium assessing Christopher Thorpe's (2024) book on cultural representations of Italy and Italians in England and Britain. It outlines key intellectual contours including conceptualizing cultural representations, using sociological concepts across traditions, and the status of sociological claims about long-term trends from a historical perspective.
David Inglisยท Journal of Cultural Analysis and Social Changeยท 2024ยท DOI 10.20897/jcasc/15780
The core problem
This paper serves as a prelude to, and putative enticement for readers to read, an interdisciplinary symposium. The symposium assesses Christopher Thorpe's (2024) book *Cultural Sociology of Cultural Representations: Visions of Italy and the Italians in England and Britain from the Renaissance to the Present Day*. The book is scrutinised from various perspectives, including history, art history, and sociology. The main intellectual contours of the symposium are set out, covering matters of conceptualising cultural representations, using sociological concepts from varied traditions to understand certain sorts of cultural phenomena, and the status of sociological claims about long-term trends in the eyes of historians. Some more unorthodox ideas are also floated.
Innovation
The symposium adopts an interdisciplinary approach, drawing on history, art history, and sociology to evaluate Thorpe's work. The methodology involves critical analysis from multiple perspectives, focusing on the conceptualisation of cultural representations, the application of sociological concepts from varied traditions to understand cultural phenomena, and the assessment of sociological claims about long-term trends as viewed by historians. The symposium also includes unorthodox ideas to stimulate further debate.
Introduction
This paper serves as a prelude to, and putative enticement for readers to read, an interdisciplinary symposium. The symposium assesses Christopher Thorpe's (2024) book *Cultural Sociology of Cultural Representations: Visions of Italy and the Italians in England and Britain from the Renaissance to the Present Day*. The book is scrutinised from various perspectives, including history, art history, and sociology. The main intellectual contours of the symposium are set out, covering matters of conceptualising cultural representations, using sociological concepts from varied traditions to understand certain sorts of cultural phenomena, and the status of sociological claims about long-term trends in the eyes of historians. Some more unorthodox ideas are also floated.
Why it matters
The discussion highlights the tensions between sociological and historical approaches to cultural representations. Thorpe's work is praised for its ambitious scope but critiqued for its treatment of historical evidence. The symposium underscores the need for interdisciplinary dialogue to refine concepts and methods. The unorthodox ideas, such as rethinking the role of agency in cultural representation, provoke further reflection on the relationship between sociology and history.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ