Humaniora editorial
Open AccessOA2024
On the Role of the Ethical Theory in the Structure of Artificial Moral Agents in the Cultural Field of the Information Society
The study examines how ethical theories—particularly deontology and utilitarianism—can be formalized and embedded into artificial moral agents, arguing that utilitarianism is more amenable to computational representation while deontology better captures the actual process of moral decision-making. It concludes that agents must be able to construct their own ethical models rather than merely implement pre-formalized theories.
A. Antipov· Concept philosophy religion culture· 2024· DOI 10.24833/2541-8831-2024-2-30-8-21
The core problem
The paper actualizes the ethical and philosophical aspects of creating artificial intelligence systems and artificial moral agents (AMAs). The relevance is justified by the need to comprehend the formation of digital ethics, which occupies an increasingly dominant position in modern culture. The author notes the ambiguous nature of digital ethics and its inchoate subject of analysis. Ethical characteristics are part of the general cultural space of embedding intellectual systems into the human world and reflecting on this process. The aim is to analyze ethical theory in the structure of AMAs. The tasks are: (1) consider various strategies of ethical regulation from the point of view of their formalization for use in intelligent systems, paying special attention to negative manifestations and arguments against AMAs—both well-known (malicious use, existential experiences of mankind as a species) and specific to philosophy and ethics (manipulation of behavior through emulation of emotions, remote access and use); (2) raise issues related to the ethics of intelligent systems and present controversies surrounding their implementation; (3) analyze deontology and utilitarianism as theories suitable for formalization and use in the structure and architecture of AMAs. The methodology includes ethical and humanitarian expertise and case analysis. The main material is theoretical models of AMAs and the embedding of ethical theories such as deontology and utilitarianism. A case study of a social robot is used to examine differences between deontology and utilitarianism in case resolution.
Innovation
The research employs the methodology of ethical and humanitarian expertise and case analysis. Ethical and humanitarian expertise involves a systematic evaluation of ethical implications, risks, and values embedded in technological systems. Case analysis is used to examine concrete instances of AMA design and decision-making, particularly through a case study of a social robot. The main material for the research is theoretical models of realization of AMAs and the embedding of ethical theories such as deontology and utilitarianism into them. The author analyzes various strategies of ethical regulation from the perspective of their formalization for use in intelligent systems. The study also considers arguments against the creation of AMAs, including both well-known concerns (malicious use, existential experiences of mankind as a species) and more specific philosophical and ethical issues (manipulation of behavior through emulation of emotions, the problem of remote access and use). The methodology allows for a comparative analysis of ethical theories in terms of their suitability for formalization and implementation in AMA architectures.
Introduction
The paper actualizes the ethical and philosophical aspects of creating artificial intelligence systems and artificial moral agents (AMAs). The relevance is justified by the need to comprehend the formation of digital ethics, which occupies an increasingly dominant position in modern culture. The author notes the ambiguous nature of digital ethics and its inchoate subject of analysis. Ethical characteristics are part of the general cultural space of embedding intellectual systems into the human world and reflecting on this process. The aim is to analyze ethical theory in the structure of AMAs. The tasks are: (1) consider various strategies of ethical regulation from the point of view of their formalization for use in intelligent systems, paying special attention to negative manifestations and arguments against AMAs—both well-known (malicious use, existential experiences of mankind as a species) and specific to philosophy and ethics (manipulation of behavior through emulation of emotions, remote access and use); (2) raise issues related to the ethics of intelligent systems and present controversies surrounding their implementation; (3) analyze deontology and utilitarianism as theories suitable for formalization and use in the structure and architecture of AMAs. The methodology includes ethical and humanitarian expertise and case analysis. The main material is theoretical models of AMAs and the embedding of ethical theories such as deontology and utilitarianism. A case study of a social robot is used to examine differences between deontology and utilitarianism in case resolution.
Why it matters
The discussion centers on the implications of embedding ethical theories into AMAs. The author argues that the use of utilitarianism as moral arithmetic is advantageous for formalization because it allows each action and its consequences to be represented with a quantitative parameter, enabling computational decision-making. However, deontology's strength lies in its ability to construct a theory of permitted and prohibited actions that better reflects the actual process of doing an act. The difficulty with deontology is the correlation of categories and the category of permissibility, which is neither forbidden nor obligatory, making it hard to identify as a separate use case. This leads to the conclusion that it is not enough to simply formalize an ethical theory; it is necessary to enable artificial agents to construct an ethical model on their own. This implies a shift from pre-programmed ethical rules to adaptive, learning-based ethical reasoning. The paper also highlights negative manifestations and arguments against AMAs, including manipulation of behavior through emulation of emotions and issues of remote access and use. These concerns underscore the need for robust ethical frameworks and oversight. The author suggests that ethical and humanitarian expertise is crucial for evaluating AMAs and their integration into the cultural field of the information society.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…