Pertanian & Lingkungan editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Pluralism, Paralysis, Practice: Making Environmental Knowledge Usable
An interview study of IPBES experts reveals three approaches—integrationist, parallelist, and pragmatist—to managing diverse knowledge in environmental science-policy interfaces. The paper argues that avoiding formalization allows contextually sensitive practices to emerge.
J. White; R. Lidskog· Ecosystems and People· 2023· DOI 10.1080/26395916.2022.2160822
The core problem
The global environmental science-policy interface has become increasingly pluralistic, incorporating social scientists and Indigenous and local knowledge alongside natural science. This pluralisation presents political, normative, and epistemic challenges for expert organisations, including how knowledge is managed, validated, made policy-relevant, and presented to decision-makers. The paper investigates these challenges through an interview study of experts involved in the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES).
Innovation
The authors conducted an interview study with experts participating in IPBES. The study qualitatively analyzes the approaches these experts take to handle knowledge pluralism, focusing on how they negotiate challenges related to ontology, validity, policy relevance, and presentation.
Introduction
The global environmental science-policy interface has become increasingly pluralistic, incorporating social scientists and Indigenous and local knowledge alongside natural science. This pluralisation presents political, normative, and epistemic challenges for expert organisations, including how knowledge is managed, validated, made policy-relevant, and presented to decision-makers. The paper investigates these challenges through an interview study of experts involved in the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES).
Why it matters
Rather than championing any single approach, the paper explores their origins and how they negotiate paralyses to the timeliness of work. It finds that by avoiding ultimate formalisation of how value and knowledge pluralism are handled, IPBES allows more contextually sensitive practices to come to the fore. The paper concludes by discussing implications for environmental expertise more broadly, suggesting that flexibility and contextual sensitivity are crucial for making pluralistic knowledge usable in policy contexts.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…