Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2025
Political Conflict between Islamic Law and National Law in Indonesia
This study critically examines the political conflict between Islamic law and national law in Indonesia, revealing how recurring tensions have produced a legal system marked by compromise, inconsistency, and injustice for vulnerable groups. It calls for bold legal reforms oriented toward universal justice and human rights.
Rizal Al-Hamid; Mohamad Sobrun Jamil; Rodhotun Nimah; Mahrus Alwi Hasan Siregar; Supriyadiยท Insaniยท 2025ยท DOI 10.65586/insani.v1i1.4
The core problem
The study aims to critically, deeply, and integratively explore the dynamics of political conflicts between Islamic law and national law in Indonesia at the levels of discourse, legislative practice, and social implications. The tension between demands for formalisation of Islamic law by conservative groups and state efforts to maintain the supremacy of pluralistic, constitutional national law has created a legal system fraught with compromise, inconsistency, and injustice for vulnerable and minority groups. The law often becomes a tool for legitimising identity and power rather than an instrument of substantive justice and human rights protection. This situation demands courage from the state and society to break free from pragmatic compromises and narrow identity politics, and to push for legal reforms oriented towards universal justice.
Innovation
The study utilises a qualitative approach with structured and critical library research methods. It relies on tracing, examining, and analysing various authoritative sources to explore the political conflicts between Islamic law and national law in Indonesia. This methodological choice allows for an in-depth examination of the discourse, legislative practices, and social implications surrounding the issue.
Introduction
The study aims to critically, deeply, and integratively explore the dynamics of political conflicts between Islamic law and national law in Indonesia at the levels of discourse, legislative practice, and social implications. The tension between demands for formalisation of Islamic law by conservative groups and state efforts to maintain the supremacy of pluralistic, constitutional national law has created a legal system fraught with compromise, inconsistency, and injustice for vulnerable and minority groups. The law often becomes a tool for legitimising identity and power rather than an instrument of substantive justice and human rights protection. This situation demands courage from the state and society to break free from pragmatic compromises and narrow identity politics, and to push for legal reforms oriented towards universal justice.
Why it matters
The analysis highlights that the political conflict between Islamic law and national law in Indonesia reflects broader struggles over identity, power, and justice. The law is frequently used to legitimise identity and power rather than to serve substantive justice and human rights. This situation demands the courage of the state and all elements of society to break free from the trap of pragmatic compromises and narrow identity politics, and to boldly push for legal reforms oriented towards universal justice. The study underscores the need for a legal system that upholds pluralism, constitutional supremacy, and human rights protection for all, including vulnerable and minority groups.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ