Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2023

Politicization of Science in COVID-19 Vaccine Communication: Comparing US Politicians, Medical Experts, and Government Agencies

This study compares COVID-19 vaccine communication by U.S. politicians, medical experts, and government agencies, finding that politicians heavily politicized the issue while experts did not, and that agencies fell in between but leaned toward experts. Infection rates and state political leanings significantly influenced agencies' politicization.
Alvin Zhou; Wen-Lin Liu; A. Yang· Political Communication· 2023· DOI 10.1080/10584609.2023.2201184

The core problem

The COVID-19 pandemic thrust science into the political spotlight, particularly regarding vaccine development and distribution. While vaccines are typically a domain of medical expertise, their rapid development and rollout during a polarized political climate made them a subject of intense political debate. This study addresses a critical gap in political communication research: how different actors—politicians, medical experts, and government agencies—communicate about science, and under what conditions government agencies politicize scientific issues. The authors propose a language-based definition of politicization of science, positioning it on a continuum between purely political and purely medical discourse. They then apply machine learning to classify and measure politicization in social media posts, focusing on Facebook communication by U.S. government agencies over two years. The study aims to answer: (1) How do politicians, experts, and agencies differ in their politicization of COVID-19 vaccines? (2) How do contextual factors such as infection rates, state political leaning, and jurisdiction level influence agencies' politicization? The findings contribute to understanding the incumbency effect and government communication as an emerging area in political communication.

Innovation

The researchers constructed two reference corpora: a political corpus (tweets from U.S. politicians) and a medical corpus (posts from medical experts), representing the extremes of politicization. They developed a language-based definition of politicization of science, identifying subtle linguistic indicators such as the use of political keywords, partisan framing, and emotive language. A machine learning classifier was trained to detect these indicators and score texts on a continuous politicization scale. The classifier was then applied to two years of Facebook posts from U.S. government agencies (e.g., health departments, governors' offices) to measure their degree of politicization. The dataset included posts from agencies at various jurisdiction levels (state, county, city) and from states with different political leanings. Contextual data on COVID-19 infection rates were also collected. The analysis employed statistical models to examine how infection rates, state political leaning, and jurisdiction level affected agencies' politicization tendencies, controlling for relevant factors. The classifier's performance was validated, ensuring reliable measurement of politicization.
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic thrust science into the political spotlight, particularly regarding vaccine development and distribution. While vaccines are typically a domain of medical expertise, their rapid development and rollout during a polarized political climate made them a subject of intense political debate. This study addresses a critical gap in political communication research: how different actors—politicians, medical experts, and government agencies—communicate about science, and under what conditions government agencies politicize scientific issues. The authors propose a language-based definition of politicization of science, positioning it on a continuum between purely political and purely medical discourse. They then apply machine learning to classify and measure politicization in social media posts, focusing on Facebook communication by U.S. government agencies over two years. The study aims to answer: (1) How do politicians, experts, and agencies differ in their politicization of COVID-19 vaccines? (2) How do contextual factors such as infection rates, state political leaning, and jurisdiction level influence agencies' politicization? The findings contribute to understanding the incumbency effect and government communication as an emerging area in political communication.

Why it matters

The study offers a novel language-based operationalization of politicization of science, demonstrating that politicization can be measured on a continuum using machine learning. The finding that government agencies generally leaned toward medical expertise is encouraging, yet the significant variation based on contextual factors highlights the vulnerability of scientific communication to political influence. The negative relationship between infection rates and politicization suggests that agencies prioritize scientific messaging during crises, aligning with a public health imperative. However, the higher politicization in Democratic-leaning states warrants deeper exploration: it may reflect a response to political pressures, such as countering misinformation or advocating for policies that became politically contested. The absence of jurisdiction-level differences indicates that politicization is not simply a top-down phenomenon but is shaped by local political climates. The authors discuss the incumbency effect, where agencies may align with the incumbent administration's framing, and propose government communication as a vital area for political communication research. They call for further studies on how agencies navigate the tension between scientific integrity and political pressures, and how audiences respond to politicized versus scientific messaging. The implications extend to public trust in science and the effectiveness of health communication during crises.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…