Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2023

Power and Truth in Science-Related Populism: Rethinking the Role of Knowledge and Expertise in Climate Politics

This article challenges the view that populism is inherently anti-science and a barrier to climate action. It argues for a more inclusive conception of populism and a critical account of expertise, showing how populist critiques can be reconciled with expert knowledge to foster effective climate movements.
J. Meyer· Political Studies· 2023· DOI 10.1177/00323217231160370

The core problem

Populism is often characterized as a rejection of scientific expertise and a key obstacle to societies’ ability to address the climate crisis today. The author challenges this account, arguing for a more inclusive conception of populism and a more critical account of expertise. The paper delineates a range of responses to the challenges of climate politics in populist times, with two primary aims: first, to highlight limitations of “anti-populist” responses among proponents of climate change action; and second, to lean into populist criticisms of elite expertise by showing how some challenges to dominant forms of science and elite power are themselves expert knowledge and integral to promising movements that address climate change.

Innovation

The article employs conceptual analysis and normative political theory. It critically examines the relationship between populism, science, and expertise, drawing on examples from climate politics to illustrate its arguments. The methodology involves deconstructing the binary between populism and expertise, and proposing a reconceptualization of expertise as immersed in the common world rather than separated from it.
Introduction
Populism is often characterized as a rejection of scientific expertise and a key obstacle to societies’ ability to address the climate crisis today. The author challenges this account, arguing for a more inclusive conception of populism and a more critical account of expertise. The paper delineates a range of responses to the challenges of climate politics in populist times, with two primary aims: first, to highlight limitations of “anti-populist” responses among proponents of climate change action; and second, to lean into populist criticisms of elite expertise by showing how some challenges to dominant forms of science and elite power are themselves expert knowledge and integral to promising movements that address climate change.

Why it matters

The author argues for a more inclusive conception of populism that recognizes its potential to democratize knowledge production and challenge entrenched power. A critical account of expertise is necessary to distinguish expertise from elitism. Expertise should be recognized in caring relations to the subjects of knowledge; it is not manifest as separation from the common world, but as immersion in it. This reconceptualization allows for a more productive engagement between climate movements and expert knowledge, fostering responses to climate politics that are both scientifically informed and democratically legitimate. The paper concludes by outlining implications for climate policy and movement strategy, emphasizing the need to lean into populist criticisms while upholding rigorous standards of expertise.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…