Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Reciprocity in Public International Law
This book challenges the view that reciprocity is opposed to communitarian interests in international law, arguing instead that it is linked to the sovereign equality of States. It analyzes reciprocity's roles in treaties, treatment of individuals, law execution, and international courts.
Arianna Whelanยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1017/9781108980173
The core problem
The book opens by contesting a common perception: that reciprocity in public international law is either antithetical to communitarian interests or merely a label for reactions to wrongful conduct. The author, Arianna Whelan, argues that reciprocity is instead structurally tied to the sovereign equality of States. This reframing sets the stage for an in-depth conceptual analysis followed by a examination of reciprocity across several fields of international law.
Innovation
The methodology is doctrinal and analytical. The book first dissects the concept of reciprocity and identifies its defining elements. It then applies this conceptual framework to four areas: the law of treaties, the treatment of individuals, the execution of international law, and the jurisdiction of international courts and tribunals. In each area, both traditional and contemporary examples are analyzed to demonstrate how reciprocity operates and relates to the structure of international law.
Introduction
The book opens by contesting a common perception: that reciprocity in public international law is either antithetical to communitarian interests or merely a label for reactions to wrongful conduct. The author, Arianna Whelan, argues that reciprocity is instead structurally tied to the sovereign equality of States. This reframing sets the stage for an in-depth conceptual analysis followed by a examination of reciprocity across several fields of international law.
Why it matters
The book disputes the communitarian critique by demonstrating that reciprocity and community interests are not mutually exclusive. Instead, reciprocity, grounded in sovereign equality, provides a framework within which communitarian norms can operate. The author suggests that understanding reciprocity's structural role is essential for comprehending how international law functions and evolves. The discussion implies that ignoring reciprocity's centrality may lead to incomplete or misleading accounts of international legal order.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ