Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Reconciling Constitutional Rules and International Laws: A Doctrinal Study on the Innovative Role of Constitutional Reconciliation in Iraq and Egypt
This study examines the conflict between constitutional rules and international rules through case studies of Iraq and Egypt, proposing constitutional reconciliation as a novel jurisdiction to harmonize domestic and international legal frameworks without compromising either.
A. al-Dulaimi; Mohammed Abd Abas Al-Esawy· UUM Journal of Legal Studies· 2024· DOI 10.32890/uumjls2024.15.2.4
The core problem
The research addresses the inherent tension between constitutional rules and international rules, focusing on the emerging jurisdiction of constitutional reconciliation. The central inquiry is to determine the prevailing legal framework—domestic law or international treaty—when conflicts arise, particularly in cases where constitutional provisions lack specified applicable laws and international treaties intersect with or deviate from domestic legislation. The study aims to elucidate the mechanisms employed by domestic judges, utilizing constitutional reconciliation, to rectify such conflicts. The importance of this study lies in developing an effective resolution mechanism to harmonize international law with domestic legal frameworks, ensuring the preservation of both sets of rules without compromising either. The research is grounded in a comprehensive understanding of international law regarding the authority of constitutional judges and employs a doctrinal study methodology complemented by analytical methods. By integrating the jurisdiction of constitutional reconciliation into the methodology and using Iraq and Egypt as case studies, the research contributes to a nuanced comprehension of how constitutional judges can navigate and harmonize the interplay between domestic and international legal frameworks.
Innovation
The research employs a doctrinal study methodology to investigate the conflict between constitutional rules and international rules. A systematic analysis of legal principles, precedents, and existing literature provides a comprehensive understanding of the intricate dynamics involved in resolving conflicts between constitutional provisions and international rules. The analytical method is complemented by the doctrinal study, which involves a thorough examination of legal texts, judicial decisions, and scholarly writings. The study focuses on case studies in Iraq and Egypt to identify crucial criteria for addressing conflicts within the legal framework. The methodology includes a comparative analysis of how constitutional judges in both countries utilize constitutional reconciliation when confronted with conflicts between domestic law and international treaties. This approach allows for an in-depth exploration of the mechanisms and principles underlying constitutional reconciliation, and how these can be applied to harmonize international law with domestic legal frameworks.
Introduction
The research addresses the inherent tension between constitutional rules and international rules, focusing on the emerging jurisdiction of constitutional reconciliation. The central inquiry is to determine the prevailing legal framework—domestic law or international treaty—when conflicts arise, particularly in cases where constitutional provisions lack specified applicable laws and international treaties intersect with or deviate from domestic legislation. The study aims to elucidate the mechanisms employed by domestic judges, utilizing constitutional reconciliation, to rectify such conflicts. The importance of this study lies in developing an effective resolution mechanism to harmonize international law with domestic legal frameworks, ensuring the preservation of both sets of rules without compromising either. The research is grounded in a comprehensive understanding of international law regarding the authority of constitutional judges and employs a doctrinal study methodology complemented by analytical methods. By integrating the jurisdiction of constitutional reconciliation into the methodology and using Iraq and Egypt as case studies, the research contributes to a nuanced comprehension of how constitutional judges can navigate and harmonize the interplay between domestic and international legal frameworks.
Why it matters
The analysis delves into the nuanced conflicts arising in the absence of specified applicable laws in constitutional provisions, particularly where international treaties intersect with or deviate from domestic legislation. It elucidates the mechanisms employed by domestic judges, utilizing constitutional reconciliation, when confronted with conflicts between provisions in domestic law and those in treaties. The central inquiry focuses on determining the prevailing legal framework—domestic law or international treaty—with constitutional reconciliation emerging as a novel jurisdiction to rectify such conflicts. The discussion underscores the importance of constitutional reconciliation to harmonize international law with domestic legal frameworks. Grounded in a comprehensive understanding of international law regarding the authority of constitutional judges, the analytical method is complemented by the doctrinal study. By integrating the jurisdiction of constitutional reconciliation into the methodology and employing Iraq and Egypt as case studies, this research contributes to a nuanced comprehension of how constitutional judges can navigate and harmonize the interplay between domestic and international legal frameworks. This approach ensures the preservation of both sets of rules without compromising either, advancing our understanding of the complexities involved in addressing conflicts between constitutional and international rules through the innovative lens of constitutional reconciliation.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…