Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2025
Reconstructing Islamic Family Law in ASEAN: A Normative Analysis of Marriage, Divorce, and Inheritance in Plural Legal Systems
This study analyzes efforts to reconstruct Islamic family law in Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore, focusing on marriage, divorce, and inheritance. It proposes a normative framework based on contextual ijtihad and maqāṣid al-sharīʿah to promote legal integration that is fair and responsive to social change.
Teuku Hafid Hududillah; Shofiatun Nikmah; Fahmi Hamdi; Tate Agape Bawana· ASEAN Journal of Islamic Studies and Civilization (AJISC)· 2025· DOI 10.62976/ajisc.v2i2.1427
The core problem
The study addresses the reconstruction of Islamic family law within the pluralistic legal systems of three ASEAN countries: Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore. The central problem revolves around the convergence of Islamic law, state law, and customary or civil legal systems in matters of marriage, divorce, and inheritance. The research gap identified is the absence of an adequate normative theoretical framework in previous literature that can bridge the need for harmonization between Sharia law and constitutional principles and human rights in the pluralistic legal context of ASEAN. The objective is to analyze the doctrinal foundations of classical fiqh and codified provisions, explore interactions and jurisdictional boundaries between Islamic law and national legal systems, and formulate a normative framework for reconstruction that is more adaptive to pluralistic contexts and substantive justice values.
Innovation
The study employs a normative legal approach through literature review, comparative legal analysis, and the theory of maqāṣid al-sharīʿah as evaluative instruments. This methodology allows for a doctrinal examination of classical fiqh sources and codified statutes, alongside a comparative assessment of how Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore manage the interface between Islamic family law and their respective national legal frameworks. The maqāṣid al-sharīʿah framework serves as a normative yardstick to evaluate the extent to which existing provisions and proposed reconstructions align with the higher objectives of Islamic law, particularly substantive justice and responsiveness to social change.
Introduction
The study addresses the reconstruction of Islamic family law within the pluralistic legal systems of three ASEAN countries: Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore. The central problem revolves around the convergence of Islamic law, state law, and customary or civil legal systems in matters of marriage, divorce, and inheritance. The research gap identified is the absence of an adequate normative theoretical framework in previous literature that can bridge the need for harmonization between Sharia law and constitutional principles and human rights in the pluralistic legal context of ASEAN. The objective is to analyze the doctrinal foundations of classical fiqh and codified provisions, explore interactions and jurisdictional boundaries between Islamic law and national legal systems, and formulate a normative framework for reconstruction that is more adaptive to pluralistic contexts and substantive justice values.
Why it matters
The study interprets the results through the lens of maqāṣid al-sharīʿah, arguing that the reconstruction of Islamic family law should be guided by contextual ijtihad to achieve substantive justice. The integrative approach in Indonesia is seen as more conducive to legal integration, while Malaysia's dual system risks fragmentation and jurisdictional uncertainty. Singapore's limited recognition model offers stability but may constrain the full application of Islamic law. The authors recommend a reconstruction model based on contextual ijtihad and maqāṣid principles to promote legal integration that is fair, responsive to social change, and consistent with constitutional rights. This model emphasizes the need to bridge the gap between Sharia law and human rights frameworks, ensuring that Islamic family law remains relevant and just in pluralistic societies. The discussion also underscores the importance of harmonizing legal provisions with international human rights standards, particularly regarding gender equality and the rights of children, as part of a broader effort to reform Islamic family law in ASEAN.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…