Pendidikan editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Reliability and Interpretability in Science and Deep Learning
This digest examines the epistemological differences between deep neural network models and traditional scientific models, focusing on how model assumptions and epistemic complexity affect reliability and interpretability. It argues that the high epistemic complexity of DNNs hinders reliability assessment and long-term progress, and that interpretability is a precondition for plausible reliability evaluation.
L. Scorzatoยท Minds and Machinesยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1007/s11023-024-09682-0
The core problem
The paper addresses the growing importance of reliability in Machine Learning (ML), particularly Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), and the need to integrate standard error analysis with epistemological analysis. The author argues that standard error analysis alone is insufficient because DNN models differ significantly from traditional scientific models. The central problem is the illusion of theory-free science: all models, including ML models, rely on assumptions. The paper aims to analyze these assumptions through the lens of epistemic complexity and to connect epistemic complexity with interpretability, showing that interpretability is a precondition for assessing reliability. The scope includes comparison between traditional scientific models and DNNs, with brief consideration of Random Forest (RF) and Logistic Regression (LR) models.
Innovation
The methodology is conceptual and epistemological analysis rather than empirical experimentation. The author examines model assumptions in both ML and traditional science, emphasizing their ubiquitous role. The analysis proceeds by defining and applying the concept of epistemic complexity to model assumptions, arguing that this complexity is language-independent. The paper then relates epistemic complexity to interpretability as discussed in responsible AI. The comparison focuses on DNNs versus traditional scientific models, with RF and LR as additional points of reference. No specific equations or diagrams are presented in the source text; the analysis is qualitative and philosophical.
Introduction
The paper addresses the growing importance of reliability in Machine Learning (ML), particularly Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), and the need to integrate standard error analysis with epistemological analysis. The author argues that standard error analysis alone is insufficient because DNN models differ significantly from traditional scientific models. The central problem is the illusion of theory-free science: all models, including ML models, rely on assumptions. The paper aims to analyze these assumptions through the lens of epistemic complexity and to connect epistemic complexity with interpretability, showing that interpretability is a precondition for assessing reliability. The scope includes comparison between traditional scientific models and DNNs, with brief consideration of Random Forest (RF) and Logistic Regression (LR) models.
Why it matters
The discussion centers on the implications of the findings for the assessment of reliability in ML. The author argues that standard error analysis, while necessary, is insufficient because it does not account for the epistemological differences between DNNs and traditional models. The high epistemic complexity of DNNs means that their assumptions are numerous and opaque, making it difficult to evaluate reliability. This also limits the potential for long-term progress, as understanding and refining assumptions is crucial for scientific advancement. The paper suggests some potential ways forward, though these are not detailed in the source. The connection between epistemic complexity and interpretability clarifies the black-box problem: interpretability is not merely a matter of individual skill but is tied to the model's inherent complexity. Therefore, interpretability is essential for any plausible reliability assessment. The analysis also implies that responsible AI practices should prioritize reducing epistemic complexity or developing methods to handle it.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ