Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Researching the Gap: Women in Latin American Political Science
Goldfrank and Welp map the gender balance in Latin American political science, finding significant underrepresentation of women in faculty positions and journal editorial roles, with a more pronounced gap in journals based within the region compared to those outside.
Benjamin Goldfrank; Yanina Welpยท Journal of Politics in Latin Americaยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1177/1866802X231213384
The core problem
The paper addresses the persistent gender gap in political science across Latin America. While women have made inroads into the discipline, the authors aim to quantify the extent of underrepresentation in both academic departments and scholarly journals. The study covers 16 Latin American countries, examining over 100 political science departments, as well as 69 journals published in Latin America and 16 Latin Americanist journals based in Canada, the United States, and Europe. The central research question is whether the proportion of female faculty members corresponds to the proportion of women serving in editorial roles, such as editors, editorial board members, and advisory committee members. The authors hypothesize that a significant gender gap remains and that it may be more severe in journals based in Latin America.
Innovation
The authors conducted a comprehensive mapping exercise. They collected data on the number of female professors in political science departments across 16 Latin American countries, identifying over 100 departments. For journals, they examined 69 political science journals published in Latin America and 16 Latin Americanist journals from outside the region. For each journal, they recorded the gender of editors, editorial board members, and advisory committee members. The analysis compares the proportion of women in faculty positions with their representation in journal editorial roles. The study does not specify the exact sampling method or response rate, but it provides a broad cross-national comparison. The data likely come from institutional websites and journal mastheads. The authors use descriptive statistics to illustrate the gender gap and compare regional differences.
Introduction
The paper addresses the persistent gender gap in political science across Latin America. While women have made inroads into the discipline, the authors aim to quantify the extent of underrepresentation in both academic departments and scholarly journals. The study covers 16 Latin American countries, examining over 100 political science departments, as well as 69 journals published in Latin America and 16 Latin Americanist journals based in Canada, the United States, and Europe. The central research question is whether the proportion of female faculty members corresponds to the proportion of women serving in editorial roles, such as editors, editorial board members, and advisory committee members. The authors hypothesize that a significant gender gap remains and that it may be more severe in journals based in Latin America.
Why it matters
The authors interpret the findings as evidence of structural barriers to women's advancement in political science in Latin America. The worse gap in Latin American journals may reflect broader societal gender norms, implicit biases in hiring and promotion, and the concentration of women in teaching-focused roles rather than research-intensive positions. The study suggests that the gender gap in editorial roles is not merely a pipeline issue, as women are present in the discipline but not in leadership positions. The authors call for greater awareness and institutional reforms to address these disparities. They also note the need for further research to understand the mechanisms behind the gap, such as networking opportunities, publication biases, and work-life balance challenges. The paper contributes to the literature on gender inequality in academia and provides a baseline for future monitoring.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ