Humaniora editorial
Resource-rational contractualism: A triple theory of moral cognition
The core problem
Innovation
The authors develop their theory through conceptual analysis and synthesis of existing literature across multiple disciplines. They argue that many well-studied elements of moral cognition—such as reasoning about others’ utilities (consequentialist reasoning) and evaluating intrinsic ethical properties of actions (deontological reasoning)—can be understood as resource-rational approximations of a contractualist ideal. The methodology involves formalizing the resource-rational approach, where agents optimize a trade-off between the benefits of more accurate moral judgments and the costs of computation. This is expressed mathematically as:
where is the utility of judgment , is its computational cost, and is a resource parameter. The authors also discuss how this framework explains the flexibility of moral minds—how moral rules and standards are created, updated, overridden, and applied to novel cases.
Why it matters
Who should read this
Opening member content…