Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Humaniora editorial

Open AccessOA2024

Resource-rational contractualism: A triple theory of moral cognition

This digest presents resource-rational contractualism, a theory proposing that moral judgments arise from resource-rational approximations of an ideal contractualist bargaining process. It integrates consequentialist and deontological reasoning as heuristics for identifying mutually beneficial agreements under cognitive constraints.
Nisheeth Srivastava; Arjun Mitra; Ramya Mudumba; Hariharan Purohit; Divya Pathak· Behavioral and Brain Sciences· 2024· DOI 10.1017/S0140525X24001067

The core problem

Moral psychology has long grappled with the apparent fragmentation of moral cognition, often described as a conflict between intuitive (deontological) and deliberative (consequentialist) systems. The authors propose a unifying framework: resource-rational contractualism. Drawing on contractualist philosophy, they posit that ideal moral judgments are those that would be agreed upon by rational bargaining agents. This idea finds support across philosophy, psychology, economics, biology, and cultural evolution. However, as a practical matter, negotiating every interpersonal interaction is infeasible. Thus, the theory argues that people use abstractions and heuristics to efficiently identify mutually beneficial arrangements. This perspective naturally integrates contractualist, consequentialist, and deontological concerns into a triple theory of moral cognition.

Innovation

The authors develop their theory through conceptual analysis and synthesis of existing literature across multiple disciplines. They argue that many well-studied elements of moral cognition—such as reasoning about others’ utilities (consequentialist reasoning) and evaluating intrinsic ethical properties of actions (deontological reasoning)—can be understood as resource-rational approximations of a contractualist ideal. The methodology involves formalizing the resource-rational approach, where agents optimize a trade-off between the benefits of more accurate moral judgments and the costs of computation. This is expressed mathematically as:

where is the utility of judgment , is its computational cost, and is a resource parameter. The authors also discuss how this framework explains the flexibility of moral minds—how moral rules and standards are created, updated, overridden, and applied to novel cases.

Introduction
Moral psychology has long grappled with the apparent fragmentation of moral cognition, often described as a conflict between intuitive (deontological) and deliberative (consequentialist) systems. The authors propose a unifying framework: resource-rational contractualism. Drawing on contractualist philosophy, they posit that ideal moral judgments are those that would be agreed upon by rational bargaining agents. This idea finds support across philosophy, psychology, economics, biology, and cultural evolution. However, as a practical matter, negotiating every interpersonal interaction is infeasible. Thus, the theory argues that people use abstractions and heuristics to efficiently identify mutually beneficial arrangements. This perspective naturally integrates contractualist, consequentialist, and deontological concerns into a triple theory of moral cognition.

Why it matters

The authors discuss the implications of resource-rational contractualism for moral philosophy and psychology. They argue that the theory resolves the apparent fragmentation of moral psychology by showing that the different systems are resource-rational adaptations to the problem of achieving mutual benefit. The triple theory naturally integrates contractualist, consequentialist, and deontological concerns, offering a parsimonious framework. The authors also address potential criticisms, such as the assumption of rational bargaining agents and the role of emotions in moral judgment. They suggest that emotions can be understood as resource-rational signals that guide heuristic moral judgments. Finally, they outline directions for future research, including testing the theory's predictions in behavioral experiments and extending it to cultural evolution.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…