Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2022

Responsibility in Medical Sociology: A Second, Reflexive Look

This paper challenges contemporary medical sociology's resistance to 'responsibilization' by highlighting its potential benefits from the individual's perspective, including empowerment, coping, moral dignity, and pragmatic self-reliance.
David A. Rierยท The American sociologistยท 2022ยท DOI 10.1007/s12108-022-09549-w

The core problem

Personal responsibility has become a central element in public health planning across many countries, sparking substantial debate. Contemporary medical sociology typically resists such 'responsibilization' as victim-blaming by privileged elites that obscures structural factors and inequities. This paper, based on a broad review of Anglophone medical sociology literatures, argues that taking responsibility seriously offers advantages, particularly from the individual's perspective. The authors identify four key advantages: empowerment, responsibility-as-coping-mechanism, moral dignity, and the pragmatic logic of doing for oneself rather than passively awaiting societal reforms. They also explore why sociologists and their subjects view these issues differently and suggest future research directions.

Innovation

The paper is based primarily on a broad review of contemporary Anglophone medical sociology literatures. It examines how these literatures treat responsibility and blame, synthesizing existing perspectives to build a reflexive analysis. The authors do not employ empirical data collection but rather engage in a critical interpretive synthesis of published works. This approach allows them to identify patterns in sociological discourse and contrast them with the lived experiences of individuals. The review focuses on the tension between structural critiques and individual agency, setting the stage for a reevaluation of responsibility's role in health behaviors and outcomes.
Introduction
Personal responsibility has become a central element in public health planning across many countries, sparking substantial debate. Contemporary medical sociology typically resists such 'responsibilization' as victim-blaming by privileged elites that obscures structural factors and inequities. This paper, based on a broad review of Anglophone medical sociology literatures, argues that taking responsibility seriously offers advantages, particularly from the individual's perspective. The authors identify four key advantages: empowerment, responsibility-as-coping-mechanism, moral dignity, and the pragmatic logic of doing for oneself rather than passively awaiting societal reforms. They also explore why sociologists and their subjects view these issues differently and suggest future research directions.

Why it matters

The authors discuss possible reasons for the divergent views between sociologists and their subjects. Sociologists, often positioned as privileged elites, may emphasize structural constraints to avoid victim-blaming, while individuals may find meaning and agency in taking responsibility. This reflexive look suggests that medical sociology should reconsider its blanket resistance to responsibilization. The paper proposes future research to explore how responsibility can be supported without reinforcing inequities, and how sociological practice can better align with the lived realities of individuals. The authors argue for a balanced approach that acknowledges both structural factors and individual agency, ultimately enhancing public health interventions and ethical discourse.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ