Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2023

Revisiting Coercion as an Element of Prohibited Intervention in International Law

Marko Milanovic argues that coercion in the prohibition of intervention can be understood as either extortion (targeting the victim state's will) or control (depriving the state of sovereign choice). Many doctrinal difficulties stem from conflating these two models.
Marko Milanovicยท American Journal of International Lawยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1017/ajil.2023.40

The core problem

International law prohibits states from intervening in the internal and external affairs of other states, but only when the method of intervention is coercive. The precise meaning of 'coercion' has long been contested. Marko Milanovic's article, published in the *American Journal of International Law*, revisits this element and argues that the concept can be understood in two distinct ways, or models. The failure to distinguish between these models, he contends, explains many of the difficulties surrounding the notion of coercion. The article thus aims to clarify the legal analysis of prohibited intervention by separating two different understandings of what it means to coerce a state.

Innovation

The article employs conceptual and doctrinal analysis. Milanovic identifies two models of coercion by examining how the term is used in state practice, judicial decisions, and scholarly commentary. He then tests these models against various scenarios, including cyber operations, to illustrate their different implications. The methodology is primarily analytical, drawing on international legal theory and case law to dissect the elements of the prohibition of intervention. No empirical data or quantitative methods are used; the focus is on refining the legal concept through careful distinction.
Introduction
International law prohibits states from intervening in the internal and external affairs of other states, but only when the method of intervention is coercive. The precise meaning of 'coercion' has long been contested. Marko Milanovic's article, published in the *American Journal of International Law*, revisits this element and argues that the concept can be understood in two distinct ways, or models. The failure to distinguish between these models, he contends, explains many of the difficulties surrounding the notion of coercion. The article thus aims to clarify the legal analysis of prohibited intervention by separating two different understandings of what it means to coerce a state.

Why it matters

The distinction between coercion-as-extortion and coercion-as-control has significant implications for the law of intervention. Under the extortion model, the focus is on the coercing state's attempt to influence the victim's decision-making, which typically requires a communicated threat or demand. Under the control model, the focus shifts to the actual effect on the victim's sovereignty, regardless of whether the victim is aware of the interference. This latter model is particularly relevant to cyber operations, where a state may be deprived of control over its infrastructure or data without any explicit demand or threat.

Milanovic suggests that conflating these models leads to confusion in doctrine and inconsistent state practice. By separating them, the article provides a clearer framework for analyzing whether a particular act constitutes prohibited intervention. It also highlights the need for international law to adapt to new methods of coercion that do not fit neatly into the traditional extortion model. The analysis contributes to ongoing debates about the scope of the non-intervention principle and the challenges posed by emerging technologies.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ