Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2025

Revisiting credentialism – why qualifications matter: a theoretical exploration

This article extends social realist theorising to qualifications, arguing that while qualifications are imperfect and reproduce inequalities, they matter and should be less tightly tied to the labour market. A socially just model would serve individual, educational, occupational, and social purposes.
Leesa Wheelahan; Gavin Moodie· British Journal of Sociology of Education· 2025· DOI 10.1080/01425692.2025.2529814

The core problem

The article addresses the nature of qualifications within the sociology of education, extending social realist theorising about theoretical knowledge and curriculum. It draws on Bernstein's concept of evaluative rules to explore how qualifications function in society. The authors critique existing theories—human capital, institutional, and credentialist—for failing to recognise education as a relatively autonomous field distinct from other social fields. The central argument is that qualifications matter despite their imperfections, their contribution to reproducing social inequalities, and the need to loosen their ties to the labour market. A socially just model of qualifications is proposed, encompassing four key purposes: individual, educational, occupational, and social.

Innovation

This is a theoretical exploration, not an empirical study. The authors employ conceptual analysis grounded in Bernstein's concept of evaluative rules to theorise the nature and role of qualifications. They critically evaluate three prominent theoretical perspectives—human capital theory, institutional theory, and credentialist theory—assessing each for its insights and limitations regarding the societal role of qualifications. The analysis is situated within the social realist tradition in the sociology of education, which emphasises the relative autonomy of education as a social field. No data collection or empirical methods are reported; the methodology is purely theoretical and comparative.
Introduction
The article addresses the nature of qualifications within the sociology of education, extending social realist theorising about theoretical knowledge and curriculum. It draws on Bernstein's concept of evaluative rules to explore how qualifications function in society. The authors critique existing theories—human capital, institutional, and credentialist—for failing to recognise education as a relatively autonomous field distinct from other social fields. The central argument is that qualifications matter despite their imperfections, their contribution to reproducing social inequalities, and the need to loosen their ties to the labour market. A socially just model of qualifications is proposed, encompassing four key purposes: individual, educational, occupational, and social.

Why it matters

The discussion extends social realist theorising by applying Bernstein's evaluative rules to qualifications, thereby providing a more nuanced understanding of their societal function. The authors contend that existing theories reduce qualifications to either economic signals (human capital), institutional artefacts (institutional theory), or exclusionary credentials (credentialism), neglecting the relative autonomy of education. By theorising qualifications as having multiple purposes, the article proposes a socially just model that balances individual development, educational goals, occupational preparation, and social contribution. This model implies that policy should avoid over-coupling qualifications to labour market demands, which can exacerbate inequalities. The authors conclude that qualifications, while imperfect, are essential social instruments that require careful theoretical and normative scrutiny to enhance their transformative potential and mitigate their reproductive effects.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…