Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Social Network Analysis and Counterterrorism: A Double-Edged Sword for International Humanitarian Law
This article argues that social network analysis (SNA) is fundamentally incompatible with international humanitarian law (IHL) targeting rules because its data do not pertain to legally relevant criteria, yet SNA can offer valuable insights for IHL by illuminating intra-group dynamics to facilitate conflict classification and identify legally relevant characteristics in armed groups' networks.
Michael Moncrieff; P. Kilibarda; Gloria Gaggioliยท Journal of Conflict and Security Lawยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1093/jcsl/krae002
The core problem
The use of social network analysis (SNA) during the War on Terror has been a topic of significant political and academic discourse. SNA is an empirical method that graphically and mathematically represents interactions or relationships between nodes (e.g., individuals, organizations) and the ties that connect them. The nature and degree of interdependence among nodes are believed to provide insights into the relationships and behaviour of members within a social network. The scarcity of precise and comprehensive data on the structure, functioning, and activities of terrorist groups has prompted some states to incorporate SNA into their intelligence efforts and rely on its data for counterterrorism activities, including lethal operations. However, the compatibility of SNA with international law remains underexplored. In this article, we adopt a legal-empirical approach to elucidate SNA in accessible terms and examine the challenges it presents for international law.
Innovation
The authors employ a legal-empirical approach to elucidate SNA in accessible terms and examine the challenges it presents for international law. This approach combines legal analysis with empirical insights from SNA, allowing for a comprehensive examination of how SNA data and methods interact with IHL targeting rules. The methodology involves explaining SNA concepts and then assessing their compatibility with legal criteria.
Introduction
The use of social network analysis (SNA) during the War on Terror has been a topic of significant political and academic discourse. SNA is an empirical method that graphically and mathematically represents interactions or relationships between nodes (e.g., individuals, organizations) and the ties that connect them. The nature and degree of interdependence among nodes are believed to provide insights into the relationships and behaviour of members within a social network. The scarcity of precise and comprehensive data on the structure, functioning, and activities of terrorist groups has prompted some states to incorporate SNA into their intelligence efforts and rely on its data for counterterrorism activities, including lethal operations. However, the compatibility of SNA with international law remains underexplored. In this article, we adopt a legal-empirical approach to elucidate SNA in accessible terms and examine the challenges it presents for international law.
Why it matters
The findings underscore the importance of a nuanced understanding of SNAโs applications and limitations in the context of international law. While SNA is incompatible with IHL targeting rules, its potential benefits for conflict classification and understanding armed group dynamics suggest that SNA can be a double-edged sword. The authors argue that SNA should not be used directly for targeting decisions but can inform legal analyses of armed conflicts. This discussion highlights the need for careful consideration of how empirical methods like SNA are integrated into legal frameworks.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ