Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2024

Speaking Truth to Power: Toward a Forensic Anthropology of Advocacy and Activism

This digest summarizes Adams et al.'s argument that forensic anthropology must embrace advocacy and activism to serve marginalized communities, addressing the scope of the issues, disciplinary perceptions, and applications in casework, research, and education.
Donovan M. Adams; Juliette R. Bedard; S. Blatt; Eman Faisal; Jesse R. Goliath; Grace Gregory-Alcock; Ariel Gruenthal‐Rankin; Patricia N. Morales Morales Lorenzo; Ashley C. Smith; S. Tallman; Rylan Tegtmeyer Hawke; Hannah Whitelaw· Humans· 2024· DOI 10.3390/humans4010005

The core problem

The field of forensic anthropology has diversified, bringing unique perspectives to a previously homogeneous discipline. This diversification has been accompanied by recognizing the need for advocacy and activism to support the communities served: marginalized communities often overrepresented in the forensic population. Forensic anthropologists witness the downstream effects of colonialism, white supremacy, inequitable policies, racism, poverty, homophobia, transphobia, gun violence, and misogyny. Some argue that advocacy and activism have no place in forensic anthropological praxis. The counterarguments for engaging in advocacy and activism uphold white, heterosexual, cisgender, and ableist privilege by arguing that perceived objectivity and unbiased perspectives are more important than personally biasing experiences and positionality that supposedly jeopardize the science and expert testimony. However, advocacy and activism are not new to anthropology; they play important roles in sociocultural anthropology, archaeology, and other areas of biological anthropology, using both the scientific method and community engagement. Using a North American approach, the authors detail the scope of the issues, address how advocacy and activism are perceived in the wider discipline, and define ways to utilize advocacy and activism more broadly in casework, research, and education.

Innovation

The paper is a conceptual and review article that synthesizes literature and professional experience to build an argument for advocacy and activism in forensic anthropology. The authors adopt a North American perspective, drawing on examples from the discipline and related fields. The methodology involves: (1) identifying the scope of issues stemming from structural violence and systemic inequities that affect the forensic population; (2) examining perceptions of advocacy and activism within anthropology, including counterarguments that invoke scientific objectivity; and (3) proposing a framework for integrating advocacy and activism into casework, research, and education. The approach is grounded in critical analysis of the discipline's history and current practices, with an emphasis on reflexivity and positionality. No primary data collection or statistical analysis is reported; instead, the authors rely on scholarly sources and professional insights to support their claims.
Introduction
The field of forensic anthropology has diversified, bringing unique perspectives to a previously homogeneous discipline. This diversification has been accompanied by recognizing the need for advocacy and activism to support the communities served: marginalized communities often overrepresented in the forensic population. Forensic anthropologists witness the downstream effects of colonialism, white supremacy, inequitable policies, racism, poverty, homophobia, transphobia, gun violence, and misogyny. Some argue that advocacy and activism have no place in forensic anthropological praxis. The counterarguments for engaging in advocacy and activism uphold white, heterosexual, cisgender, and ableist privilege by arguing that perceived objectivity and unbiased perspectives are more important than personally biasing experiences and positionality that supposedly jeopardize the science and expert testimony. However, advocacy and activism are not new to anthropology; they play important roles in sociocultural anthropology, archaeology, and other areas of biological anthropology, using both the scientific method and community engagement. Using a North American approach, the authors detail the scope of the issues, address how advocacy and activism are perceived in the wider discipline, and define ways to utilize advocacy and activism more broadly in casework, research, and education.

Why it matters

The authors argue that the perceived dichotomy between objectivity and advocacy is false; all science is shaped by positionality, and acknowledging this strengthens rather than weakens the discipline. They contend that advocacy and activism are essential for forensic anthropologists to speak truth to power and to serve marginalized communities effectively. The discussion addresses counterarguments, noting that claims of unbiased perspectives often mask privileged standpoints that ignore systemic inequities. The authors propose that forensic anthropologists have an ethical responsibility to engage in advocacy and activism, using their expertise to inform policy, challenge unjust practices, and support communities. They emphasize that this does not mean sacrificing scientific rigor; rather, it means being transparent about values and using science in the service of justice. The paper concludes with a call to action for the discipline to embrace advocacy and activism as core components of praxis, and to integrate them into training, research, and professional practice. The authors suggest that this shift will lead to a more equitable and effective forensic anthropology that truly serves all communities.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…