Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Pendidikan editorial

Open AccessOA2024

Structured Shadowing as a Pedagogy

Structured shadowing enhances traditional job shadowing with pedagogical support, helping students connect theory to practice, appreciate complexity, and reflect on managerial identities. This under-utilized pedagogy addresses key challenges in management education but requires significant investment.
Davide Nicolini; Maja Koricaยท Management Learningยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1177/13505076231221531

The core problem

Management education faces persistent critiques regarding its ability to prepare students for the complexities of managerial practice. In this context, Nicolini and Korica introduce structured shadowing as a distinct pedagogy that extends traditional job shadowing by incorporating carefully designed pre-, intra-, and post-shadowing pedagogical support. Drawing on an interview-based evaluation study of final-year undergraduates in a UK business school, the authors argue that structured shadowing is a promising yet under-utilized approach to enrich management learning. The study addresses central debates in management education, particularly the challenges of substance, contextual understanding, and reflection. By enabling students to observe managers in action and engage in structured reflection, this pedagogy helps bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical application.

Innovation

The authors conducted an interview-based evaluation study involving several cohorts of final-year undergraduate students in a UK business school. The structured shadowing intervention comprised three phases: pre-shadowing preparation (e.g., setting objectives, understanding organizational context), intra-shadowing activities (e.g., observing managerial actions, note-taking), and post-shadowing debriefing and reflection (e.g., discussions, reflective essays). Data were collected through interviews with students, providing insights into their experiences and perceptions of the structured shadowing process. The qualitative analysis focused on how students connected theory to practice, appreciated managerial complexities, and reflected on their own managerial identities. The study also drew on the authors' teaching experience to contextualize findings and derive pedagogical implications.
Introduction
Management education faces persistent critiques regarding its ability to prepare students for the complexities of managerial practice. In this context, Nicolini and Korica introduce structured shadowing as a distinct pedagogy that extends traditional job shadowing by incorporating carefully designed pre-, intra-, and post-shadowing pedagogical support. Drawing on an interview-based evaluation study of final-year undergraduates in a UK business school, the authors argue that structured shadowing is a promising yet under-utilized approach to enrich management learning. The study addresses central debates in management education, particularly the challenges of substance, contextual understanding, and reflection. By enabling students to observe managers in action and engage in structured reflection, this pedagogy helps bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical application.

Why it matters

The authors argue that structured shadowing offers valuable lessons for management education by addressing the challenges of substance, contextual understanding, and reflection. It provides students with concrete experiences that ground theoretical knowledge, thereby adding substance to learning. By immersing students in real managerial contexts, it enhances contextual understanding, allowing them to appreciate the situated nature of managerial work. The structured reflective components promote reflective practice, helping students develop critical thinking and self-awareness. However, the authors acknowledge that structured shadowing demands significant investment in terms of time, resources, and coordination with organizations. Potential trade-offs include the risk of superficial observation if not properly scaffolded, and the possibility that it may reflect certain professional privileges, as access to managers may be uneven. Despite these challenges, structured shadowing represents a powerful pedagogical resource that warrants greater attention in management education.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ