Teknik & Rekayasa editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Team-Based Learning in Large Cohorts: Successes and Challenges in First Year Mechanical Engineering
This study refines team-based learning (TBL) for a large first-year mechanical engineering cohort (~350 students) over two semesters, showing enhanced engagement and exam performance, particularly for the lower quartile (5–10% mark increase), while highlighting challenges in group monitoring and hybrid TBL refinement.
AlexanderJ.G. Lunt; Steve Cayzer; Yvonne Moore; Anna M. Young· International Journal of Mechanical Engineering Education· 2024· DOI 10.1177/03064190241259305
The core problem
Maximising engagement, interaction, and providing effective feedback for large engineering cohorts is a significant challenge. Team-based learning (TBL) is a powerful approach that has been shown to be effective in overcoming these issues. However, the use of TBL for very large class sizes, particularly in engineering, is limited. This study focuses on refining TBL for a large (~350) student first-year mechanical engineering cohort. The authors—Alexander J.G. Lunt, Steve Cayzer, Yvonne Moore, and Anna M. Young—trialled and optimised TBL during tutorials over two successive academic semesters with the same group. The research addresses the gap in TBL implementation for large engineering cohorts, aiming to enhance engagement, peer-to-peer learning, and exam performance while identifying practical challenges.
Innovation
The study employed a design-based approach, trialling and optimising TBL over two successive academic semesters with the same cohort of approximately 350 first-year mechanical engineering students. Quantitative data were collected from student attendance and performance metrics, including exam scores. Qualitative insights were gathered through regular feedback from students and instructors. The TBL methodology was tailored to the large class size, with careful monitoring of group effectiveness. The intervention was implemented during tutorials, and iterative refinements were made based on ongoing feedback and observed outcomes. The study did not specify the exact TBL components (e.g., readiness assurance tests, application exercises) but emphasised the adaptation of TBL principles to a large engineering context.
Introduction
Maximising engagement, interaction, and providing effective feedback for large engineering cohorts is a significant challenge. Team-based learning (TBL) is a powerful approach that has been shown to be effective in overcoming these issues. However, the use of TBL for very large class sizes, particularly in engineering, is limited. This study focuses on refining TBL for a large (~350) student first-year mechanical engineering cohort. The authors—Alexander J.G. Lunt, Steve Cayzer, Yvonne Moore, and Anna M. Young—trialled and optimised TBL during tutorials over two successive academic semesters with the same group. The research addresses the gap in TBL implementation for large engineering cohorts, aiming to enhance engagement, peer-to-peer learning, and exam performance while identifying practical challenges.
Why it matters
The study demonstrates that TBL can be successfully implemented in large engineering cohorts, yielding measurable benefits in engagement and performance, especially for lower-quartile students. The 5–10% mark increase for this group is particularly noteworthy, as it suggests TBL can help narrow achievement gaps. However, the challenges highlight the need for careful design and monitoring. The authors note that monitoring group effectiveness is difficult in large classes, and hybrid TBL requires further refinement. The iterative optimisation over two semesters allowed for adjustments, but the study acknowledges limitations such as the lack of a control group and reliance on self-reported feedback. Future research should explore scalable monitoring strategies and refine hybrid TBL models. Overall, the study provides valuable insights for educators seeking to implement TBL in large engineering courses.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…