Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2023

The Aims and Functions of Criminal Law

Andrew Cornford examines competing claims about the aims and functions of criminal law, arguing that the debate is muddled because the meaning of 'aim' and 'function' is unclear. He identifies three plausible interpretations and concludes that criminal law has more aims and functions than any side in the debate acknowledges.
Andrew Cornfordยท Modern law reviewยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1111/1468-2230.12846

The core problem

The question of what the aims and functions of criminal law are has recently attracted significant scholarly debate. However, as Andrew Cornford observes in this article, the debate is difficult to assess because what it means to call something an aim or function of criminal law remains unclear. Competing claims about criminal law's aims and functions are often made without a shared understanding of the concepts involved, leading to confusion and talking past one another. The article therefore sets out to do two things: first, to examine what these competing claims might mean, and second, to evaluate how convincing they are when understood in those ways. The central argument is that, in each of the senses identified, criminal law has numerous aims and functions โ€“ more than all sides in the debate allow.

Innovation

The article employs conceptual analysis, a method characteristic of analytical legal philosophy. Rather than conducting empirical research or doctrinal analysis, Cornford scrutinises the language used in debates about criminal law's aims and functions. He identifies three plausible interpretations of claims that something is an aim or function of criminal law:

1. **Justificatory claims**: those that justify the retention or use of criminal law.
2. **Purposive claims**: those that criminal law is aimed at doing.
3. **Explanatory claims**: those that explain the existence or persistence of criminal law.

By distinguishing these senses, Cornford aims to bring clarity to the debate and to assess the strength of various positions when understood in each sense. The method is thus analytical and interpretive, focusing on the meaning of concepts and the logical structure of arguments rather than on empirical data.

Introduction
The question of what the aims and functions of criminal law are has recently attracted significant scholarly debate. However, as Andrew Cornford observes in this article, the debate is difficult to assess because what it means to call something an aim or function of criminal law remains unclear. Competing claims about criminal law's aims and functions are often made without a shared understanding of the concepts involved, leading to confusion and talking past one another. The article therefore sets out to do two things: first, to examine what these competing claims might mean, and second, to evaluate how convincing they are when understood in those ways. The central argument is that, in each of the senses identified, criminal law has numerous aims and functions โ€“ more than all sides in the debate allow.

Why it matters

The significance of Cornford's argument lies in its challenge to the terms of the existing debate. By showing that claims about aims and functions can be understood in at least three distinct ways, he demonstrates that many disagreements are merely verbal or rest on unexamined assumptions. Moreover, his conclusion that criminal law has numerous aims and functions in each sense undermines monistic theories that reduce criminal law to a single purpose, such as retribution, deterrence, or social protection. Instead, Cornford's analysis supports a pluralistic understanding: criminal law may simultaneously serve multiple justificatory, purposive, and explanatory roles. This has implications for how we evaluate criminal law and its institutions. For instance, justificatory claims must be assessed in light of the specific aim invoked, and explanatory claims must account for the complex social and historical factors that sustain criminal law. The article thus contributes to a more nuanced and rigorous debate about the nature and role of criminal law.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ