Hukum editorial
The Aims and Functions of Criminal Law
The core problem
Innovation
The article employs conceptual analysis, a method characteristic of analytical legal philosophy. Rather than conducting empirical research or doctrinal analysis, Cornford scrutinises the language used in debates about criminal law's aims and functions. He identifies three plausible interpretations of claims that something is an aim or function of criminal law:
1. **Justificatory claims**: those that justify the retention or use of criminal law.
2. **Purposive claims**: those that criminal law is aimed at doing.
3. **Explanatory claims**: those that explain the existence or persistence of criminal law.
By distinguishing these senses, Cornford aims to bring clarity to the debate and to assess the strength of various positions when understood in each sense. The method is thus analytical and interpretive, focusing on the meaning of concepts and the logical structure of arguments rather than on empirical data.
Why it matters
Who should read this
Opening member contentโฆ