Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2024
The Concept of Restorative Justice in the Criminal Legal System: A Breakthrough in Legal Benefits
This study analyzes the concept of restorative justice in Indonesia's criminal law system as a breakthrough in legal benefits, using an empirical juridical approach. It finds that restorative justice can be applied in cases causing financial loss or minor crimes, and its implementation depends on broader concepts of punishment beyond formal criminal law provisions.
Walim Walimยท International Journal of Law Reconstructionยท 2024ยท DOI 10.26532/ijlr.v8i1.36726
The core problem
The paper begins by noting that alternative efforts to resolve criminal cases have existed since the Dutch colonial era, even before Indonesia's independence. Currently, several forms of resolving criminal cases outside of court are in force: diversion (transferring the resolution of children's cases from the criminal justice process to a process outside criminal justice in accordance with the Juvenile Criminal Justice System Law), Afkoop (as regulated in Article 82 of the Criminal Code), and Seponeren (dismissal of cases in the public interest by the Attorney General). The research aims to analyze the concept of restorative justice in the criminal law system as a breakthrough in legal benefits. The introduction sets the stage by highlighting the historical context and existing alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, pointing to the need for a more comprehensive approach that aligns with restorative justice principles.
Innovation
The research employs an empirical juridical approach, which combines a normative juridical approach with an empirical approach. This method allows the researcher to examine both the legal norms and the practical implementation of restorative justice in the criminal justice system. The empirical juridical approach is particularly suited to this study as it enables an analysis of how restorative justice concepts are applied in practice, beyond mere theoretical legal provisions. The methodology section does not detail specific data collection techniques or sample sizes, but the approach implies a mixed-methods design that integrates doctrinal legal analysis with empirical observations of case handling.
Introduction
The paper begins by noting that alternative efforts to resolve criminal cases have existed since the Dutch colonial era, even before Indonesia's independence. Currently, several forms of resolving criminal cases outside of court are in force: diversion (transferring the resolution of children's cases from the criminal justice process to a process outside criminal justice in accordance with the Juvenile Criminal Justice System Law), Afkoop (as regulated in Article 82 of the Criminal Code), and Seponeren (dismissal of cases in the public interest by the Attorney General). The research aims to analyze the concept of restorative justice in the criminal law system as a breakthrough in legal benefits. The introduction sets the stage by highlighting the historical context and existing alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, pointing to the need for a more comprehensive approach that aligns with restorative justice principles.
Why it matters
The model for implementing restorative justice in Indonesian criminal procedural law can be found through a criminal resolution mechanism that follows a legitimate legal problem resolution approach. This is reflected in the reform of the criminal justice system in Indonesia, which is based on an evaluation of the criminal justice system. The discussion elaborates on how restorative justice represents a breakthrough in legal benefits by offering a more holistic and participatory approach to resolving criminal cases. It aligns with the broader reform agenda aimed at improving the effectiveness and legitimacy of the criminal justice system. The analysis underscores that restorative justice is not merely an alternative but a necessary evolution in legal thinking, one that prioritizes restoration over retribution.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ