Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2024
The Effects of Constitutional Court Judgments in the Context of EU Integration: The Case of Romania as an EU Member State
This digest examines the conflict between the Constitutional Court of Romania and the Court of Justice of the European Union, focusing on Romania's use of constitutional identity to limit the primacy of EU law and the effects of this conflict on constitutional decisions.
Horatius Dumbravaยท ERA Forumยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1007/s12027-024-00794-9
The core problem
The article addresses the tension between the Constitutional Court of Romania (CCR) and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) regarding the principle of primacy of EU law. It frames this conflict as an assertion of constitutional identity by the CCR, a national independent court, which challenges the settled case-law of the CJEU. The analysis focuses on two aspects: first, the use of constitutional identity by the CCR as a tool to limit the primacy of EU law, with the main argument being that the CCR is the supreme national institution tasked with ensuring the supremacy of the Romanian Constitution on Romanian territory, even concerning EU law and CJEU case-law; second, the effects of the conflict between the two jurisdictions as seen in the constitutional decisions adopted by the CCR.
Innovation
The contribution employs a doctrinal legal analysis, examining the jurisprudence of the CCR and the CJEU, and the interplay between constitutional identity and EU law primacy. It focuses on the reasoning and effects of CCR decisions that assert constitutional identity to limit the application of EU law. The analysis is structured around the two aspects mentioned: the conceptual use of constitutional identity and the practical effects of jurisdictional conflict.
Introduction
The article addresses the tension between the Constitutional Court of Romania (CCR) and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) regarding the principle of primacy of EU law. It frames this conflict as an assertion of constitutional identity by the CCR, a national independent court, which challenges the settled case-law of the CJEU. The analysis focuses on two aspects: first, the use of constitutional identity by the CCR as a tool to limit the primacy of EU law, with the main argument being that the CCR is the supreme national institution tasked with ensuring the supremacy of the Romanian Constitution on Romanian territory, even concerning EU law and CJEU case-law; second, the effects of the conflict between the two jurisdictions as seen in the constitutional decisions adopted by the CCR.
Why it matters
The discussion centers on the implications of the CCR's approach for Romania's EU membership. The use of constitutional identity as a limit to EU law primacy raises questions about the balance between national constitutional sovereignty and EU integration. The article may argue that while the CCR's role as guarantor of the Constitution is legitimate, its decisions must be reconciled with the obligations of EU membership. The effects of the conflict between jurisdictions highlight the need for dialogue and coherence in the multi-level constitutional system of the EU. The analysis contributes to the broader debate on constitutional pluralism and the role of national constitutional courts in the EU legal order.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ