Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2024
The entangled human being – a new materialist approach to anthropology of technology
This paper proposes a New Materialist approach to the anthropology of technology, drawing on Donna Haraway and Karen Barad to develop a relational, dynamic, and non-human-centered perspective that informs ethics of technology.
A. Puzio· AI and Ethics· 2024· DOI 10.1007/s43681-024-00537-z
The core problem
Technological advancements raise profound anthropological questions: How do humans differ from technology? Which human capabilities are unique? Can robots exhibit consciousness or intelligence—capacities once considered exclusively human? Despite the evident need for an anthropological lens in societal and research contexts, the philosophical anthropology of technology has not been established as a distinct discipline with a defined set of theories, especially concerning emerging technologies. The author argues that a robust anthropology of technology is essential for ethics of technology, as our understanding of humans and their relationship with technology fundamentally shapes our ethical concepts and theories. The paper aims to address this gap by utilizing a New Materialist approach, focusing particularly on the theories of Donna Haraway and Karen Barad, to explore their potential for developing a techno-anthropological framework. The goal is to outline an anthropology of technology centered on New Materialism, wherein the focus, paradoxically, is not exclusively on humans but equally on non-human entities and the entanglement with the non-human.
Innovation
The paper employs a conceptual and theoretical approach, drawing on New Materialist philosophy—specifically the works of Donna Haraway and Karen Barad—to construct a framework for the anthropology of technology. The methodology involves a critical analysis of key New Materialist concepts such as relationality, entanglement, intra-action, and diffraction, and their application to anthropological questions concerning technology. The author synthesizes these concepts to propose a techno-anthropological approach characterized by: (1) a relational perspective, (2) a dynamic and open conception of the human being, (3) attention to diversity and the dynamics of power in knowledge production and ontology, and (4) an emphasis on the non-human. This approach is developed through a close reading of Haraway's and Barad's theories, with the aim of demonstrating their relevance and potential for enriching the anthropology of technology. The paper does not rely on empirical data but rather on theoretical argumentation and conceptual innovation.
Introduction
Technological advancements raise profound anthropological questions: How do humans differ from technology? Which human capabilities are unique? Can robots exhibit consciousness or intelligence—capacities once considered exclusively human? Despite the evident need for an anthropological lens in societal and research contexts, the philosophical anthropology of technology has not been established as a distinct discipline with a defined set of theories, especially concerning emerging technologies. The author argues that a robust anthropology of technology is essential for ethics of technology, as our understanding of humans and their relationship with technology fundamentally shapes our ethical concepts and theories. The paper aims to address this gap by utilizing a New Materialist approach, focusing particularly on the theories of Donna Haraway and Karen Barad, to explore their potential for developing a techno-anthropological framework. The goal is to outline an anthropology of technology centered on New Materialism, wherein the focus, paradoxically, is not exclusively on humans but equally on non-human entities and the entanglement with the non-human.
Why it matters
The paper discusses the implications of this New Materialist approach for the anthropology of technology and for ethics of technology. It argues that the way we understand humans and their relationship with technology is fundamental for our concepts and theories in ethics of technology. A relational, dynamic, and non-human-centered anthropology challenges anthropocentric and essentialist assumptions that often underlie ethical frameworks, suggesting instead that ethical considerations must account for the entangled nature of human-technology assemblages. The author contends that this approach can lead to more nuanced and responsible ethical assessments of emerging technologies, as it attends to the distributed agency and power dynamics involved. The discussion also addresses potential criticisms, such as the risk of dissolving the human subject or neglecting human specificity, and responds by emphasizing that the New Materialist approach does not deny human particularities but situates them within a broader relational ontology. Finally, the paper outlines directions for future research, including the further development of New Materialist methodologies for empirical techno-anthropological studies and the exploration of their ethical implications in specific technological domains.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…