Ilmu Sosial editorial
The Honest Broker versus the Epistocrat: Attenuating Distrust in Science by Disentangling Science from Politics
The core problem
Innovation
The authors conducted an experimental study in which participants were exposed to one of four versions of a news item citing a scientist reporting their research and giving policy advice. The scientist's quotes varied in the direction and style of policy advice. Two styles were contrasted:
- **Epistocrat**: The scientist blurs the distinction between scientific and political claims, purporting to "prove" a policy and thereby precluding a societal debate over values and policy priorities.
- **Honest broker**: The scientist distinguishes between scientific and political claims, presenting a policy option while acknowledging the limitations of their disciplinary scientific perspective of a broader societal problem.
The experiment was conducted across three policy disputes (COVID-19 school closures, domestic air traffic ban, wolf shooting/protection), with participants randomly assigned to conditions. Trust in scientists and scientific findings was measured as the outcome variable, and political orientation was assessed to examine polarization.
Why it matters
Who should read this
Opening member content…