Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Ilmu Sosial editorial

Open AccessOA2024

The Honest Broker versus the Epistocrat: Attenuating Distrust in Science by Disentangling Science from Politics

This study experimentally tests whether scientists who act as 'honest brokers'—clearly separating scientific claims from political ones—can reduce political polarization of trust in science, compared to 'epistocrats' who blur the distinction. Across three German policy disputes, honest broker advice attenuated polarization by increasing trust among the most politically challenged individuals.
Senja Post; Nils Bienzeisler· Political Communication· 2024· DOI 10.1080/10584609.2024.2317274

The core problem

Public trust in science is generally high, but in policy disputes involving scientific issues, trust becomes polarized along political lines. Theorists of science and democracy have proposed that clearly disentangling scientific claims from political ones could mitigate this polarization. This study tests that proposition experimentally in three German public policy disputes: (a) school closures versus openings during the COVID-19 pandemic, (b) a ban on versus a continuation of domestic air traffic in view of climate change, and (c) the shooting of wolves in residential areas versus their protection. The central hypothesis is that the style of scientific policy advice—honest broker versus epistocrat—affects the polarization of trust in scientists and scientific findings.

Innovation

The authors conducted an experimental study in which participants were exposed to one of four versions of a news item citing a scientist reporting their research and giving policy advice. The scientist's quotes varied in the direction and style of policy advice. Two styles were contrasted:

- **Epistocrat**: The scientist blurs the distinction between scientific and political claims, purporting to "prove" a policy and thereby precluding a societal debate over values and policy priorities.
- **Honest broker**: The scientist distinguishes between scientific and political claims, presenting a policy option while acknowledging the limitations of their disciplinary scientific perspective of a broader societal problem.

The experiment was conducted across three policy disputes (COVID-19 school closures, domestic air traffic ban, wolf shooting/protection), with participants randomly assigned to conditions. Trust in scientists and scientific findings was measured as the outcome variable, and political orientation was assessed to examine polarization.

Introduction
Public trust in science is generally high, but in policy disputes involving scientific issues, trust becomes polarized along political lines. Theorists of science and democracy have proposed that clearly disentangling scientific claims from political ones could mitigate this polarization. This study tests that proposition experimentally in three German public policy disputes: (a) school closures versus openings during the COVID-19 pandemic, (b) a ban on versus a continuation of domestic air traffic in view of climate change, and (c) the shooting of wolves in residential areas versus their protection. The central hypothesis is that the style of scientific policy advice—honest broker versus epistocrat—affects the polarization of trust in scientists and scientific findings.

Why it matters

The findings support the theoretical proposition that separating scientific claims from political ones can mitigate polarization of trust in science. By acting as an honest broker, scientists can signal that they are not overstepping their expertise, which may increase trust among individuals who are skeptical of scientific authority in policy debates. The study has implications for science communication: scientists should clearly distinguish between scientific evidence and policy preferences, acknowledge the limits of their expertise, and avoid claiming that science "proves" a particular policy. This style of communication may foster a more constructive societal debate over values and policy priorities. The authors conclude that the honest broker style can attenuate political polarization of trust in scientists and scientific findings by enhancing trust primarily among the most politically challenged.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…