Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2022

The Italian Constitutional Court and the Use of Comparative Law: An Empirical Analysis

Paolo Passaglia empirically analyzes the Italian Constitutional Court's use of comparative and foreign law from 2000 to 2021, identifying 74 rulings with comparative references. The study measures the impact of comparative law and classifies its functions in the Court's decision-making process.
Paolo Passaglia· The Italian Review of International and Comparative Law· 2022· DOI 10.1163/27725650-02010005

The core problem

The paper investigates the use of comparative and foreign law by the Italian Constitutional Court. The author conducts an empirical study with two main purposes: first, to measure the impact of comparative law on the activity of the Court; second, to classify the functions that comparative law serves in the Court's decision-making process. The study acknowledges the methodological challenge that it is impossible to identify all cases where the Court considers comparative law. Nevertheless, references to comparative or foreign law in rulings are treated as significant hints of such use. The analysis focuses on the Court's case-law between 2000 and 2021.

Innovation

The author employs an empirical approach by examining the Italian Constitutional Court's rulings from 2000 to 2021. Through this examination, 74 rulings containing references to comparative or foreign law are identified. These references serve as the primary data for the analysis. The methodology relies on the premise that explicit citations to comparative or foreign law in rulings, while not capturing every instance of comparative consideration, provide meaningful indicators of the Court's engagement with comparative law. The dataset of 74 rulings forms the starting point for measuring the impact and classifying the functions of comparative law in the Court's legal reasoning.
Introduction
The paper investigates the use of comparative and foreign law by the Italian Constitutional Court. The author conducts an empirical study with two main purposes: first, to measure the impact of comparative law on the activity of the Court; second, to classify the functions that comparative law serves in the Court's decision-making process. The study acknowledges the methodological challenge that it is impossible to identify all cases where the Court considers comparative law. Nevertheless, references to comparative or foreign law in rulings are treated as significant hints of such use. The analysis focuses on the Court's case-law between 2000 and 2021.

Why it matters

The paper classifies the functions of comparative law in the Court's decision-making process, showing that comparative references serve multiple roles in legal reasoning. The analysis indicates that the Court's use of comparative law has become increasingly significant over time. The author discusses the implications of these findings for understanding the Court's interpretive practices and the role of comparative law in constitutional adjudication. The study contributes to the broader debate on the use of comparative law by constitutional courts, providing empirical evidence from the Italian experience. The limitations of the methodology—specifically the impossibility of capturing all instances of comparative law consideration—are acknowledged, but the identified references are argued to be significant hints that support the study's conclusions about the growing importance of comparative law.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…