Pendidikan editorial
Open AccessOA2025
The Landscape of Research on Contextualized Science Learning: A Bibliometric Network Review
A bibliometric network analysis of 935 papers reveals 13 distinct clusters of research on contextualized science learning, demonstrating how the field has evolved into 'invisible colleges' and offering a novel synthesis methodology for science education research.
Michael Giamellaro; Cory Buxton; Joseph A. Taylor; Jean-Philippe Ayotte-Beaudet; K. L'Heureux; Marie-Claude Beaudryยท Science Educationยท 2025ยท DOI 10.1002/sce.21937
The core problem
The rapid growth of science education research has made it increasingly difficult for scholars to navigate and synthesize developments across the field, especially for broad concepts that evolve along divergent paths. This study addresses this challenge by testing a novel review methodology that combines bibliometrics and network analysis to identify and characterize clusters of research focused on the relationship between school-based science learning and the contexts where science is applied, experienced, observable, or otherwise relevant. Such contexts include socio-scientific inquiry, place-based learning, and culturally-responsive pedagogy. The authors aim to provide a synthesis approach that helps researchers perceive the field as a coherent landscape of interconnected ideas or identify specific research trajectories within a broad concept.
Innovation
The researchers employed a bibliometric network analysis on a sample of 935 academic papers. This quantitative approach was complemented by qualitative data to describe research trends within clusters and to confirm that the clusters were conceptually meaningful and distinct. The methodology involved constructing a network of citations or co-citations (the abstract does not specify the exact network type) and applying clustering algorithms to identify groups of related research. The analysis revealed 13 distinct clusters of scholarship within the domain of contextualized science learning. The authors also used bibliometric indicators to characterize each cluster and qualitative interpretation to label and describe them.
Introduction
The rapid growth of science education research has made it increasingly difficult for scholars to navigate and synthesize developments across the field, especially for broad concepts that evolve along divergent paths. This study addresses this challenge by testing a novel review methodology that combines bibliometrics and network analysis to identify and characterize clusters of research focused on the relationship between school-based science learning and the contexts where science is applied, experienced, observable, or otherwise relevant. Such contexts include socio-scientific inquiry, place-based learning, and culturally-responsive pedagogy. The authors aim to provide a synthesis approach that helps researchers perceive the field as a coherent landscape of interconnected ideas or identify specific research trajectories within a broad concept.
Why it matters
The study demonstrates that bibliometric network analysis is a powerful tool for synthesizing research on broad and evolving concepts in science education. By identifying clusters of scholarship, the methodology facilitates greater understanding of how research becomes organized into invisible colleges and offers a synthesis approach to grasp interrelated lines of research within an evolving landscape. The authors suggest that this methodology has potential to identify other schools of thought or overarching themes in science education, enhancing researchers' ability to perceive the field as a coherent landscape of interconnected ideas or to identify specific research trajectories within a broad concept. The approach can help researchers navigate the vast amount of literature and synthesize developments across the field, particularly for concepts that evolve along divergent paths.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ