Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2025
The Legitimacy of Criminal Law and the Performance Crises of Penality
This article identifies three performance crises of penality—hyper-intensity, hyper-selectivity, and sentence opacity—that undermine the legitimacy of criminal law through enforcement dynamics, and proposes 'penal adequacy' grounded in moderation, non-discrimination, transparency, and sustainability.
A. Corda· Criminal Law Forum· 2025· DOI 10.1007/s10609-025-09509-2
The core problem
The legitimacy of state punishment has long been debated to justify the extreme form of government-authorized coercion that is criminal law. Rather than focusing on the abstract legitimacy of criminal law, this article examines another dimension of the debate: the legitimacy (or lack thereof) arising from the dynamics of substantive criminalization. Specifically, it addresses the “performance crises” of penality—enforcement-related failures in the implementation of the criminal law. The article identifies and discusses three distinct typologies of crisis in the deployment and enforcement of penal statutes: crises of hyper-intensity, crises of hyper-selectivity, and crises arising from sentence opacity, each undermining the legitimacy of criminal law in different ways. By addressing this gap in the theoretical literature, the article highlights the critical role of enforcement in shaping normative and policy discussions on substantive criminalization and its impact on the legitimacy of criminal law as a whole.
Innovation
The article employs a theoretical and doctrinal analysis of criminal law legitimacy, focusing on the enforcement dimension. It develops a typology of performance crises based on a review of existing literature and legal frameworks. The analysis is conceptual, aiming to bridge the gap between normative theories of criminalization and the practical realities of penal enforcement. No empirical data or case studies are presented; instead, the author synthesizes theoretical insights to propose a new framework for evaluating penal legitimacy.
Introduction
The legitimacy of state punishment has long been debated to justify the extreme form of government-authorized coercion that is criminal law. Rather than focusing on the abstract legitimacy of criminal law, this article examines another dimension of the debate: the legitimacy (or lack thereof) arising from the dynamics of substantive criminalization. Specifically, it addresses the “performance crises” of penality—enforcement-related failures in the implementation of the criminal law. The article identifies and discusses three distinct typologies of crisis in the deployment and enforcement of penal statutes: crises of hyper-intensity, crises of hyper-selectivity, and crises arising from sentence opacity, each undermining the legitimacy of criminal law in different ways. By addressing this gap in the theoretical literature, the article highlights the critical role of enforcement in shaping normative and policy discussions on substantive criminalization and its impact on the legitimacy of criminal law as a whole.
Why it matters
From this perspective, penal legitimacy should be informed by the notion of “penal adequacy”, grounded—depending on the specific type of crisis—in moderation, non-discrimination, and transparency, and, across all cases, in sustainability. This concept highlights a balanced and fair exercise of the state’s penal power—one that is measured, non-discriminatory, clearly communicated, and, overall, capable of achieving its objectives in a sustainable manner. The article argues that addressing these performance crises is essential for restoring and maintaining the legitimacy of criminal law. By focusing on enforcement dynamics, it provides a novel framework for evaluating penal systems and offers guidance for policy reforms aimed at achieving penal adequacy.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…