Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2023

The Role of Islamic Law in Enriching the Decisions of the Indonesian Constitutional Court

This digest examines the role of Islamic Law in enriching the legal considerations of Indonesian Constitutional Court decisions, highlighting that while Islamic Law has been referenced in 20 judicial review cases, it served as the basis for consideration in only six. The authors argue that Islamic legal nuances are present in several decisions, reflecting an ongoing interaction between Islamic Law and positive law in Indonesia.
Z. Aditya; Abdul Basid Fuadi; Rizkisyabana Yulistyaputriยท Frontiers in Lawยท 2023ยท DOI 10.6000/2817-2302.2023.02.04

The core problem

The article addresses the role of Islamic Law in enriching the legal considerations of Indonesian Constitutional Court decisions. As one of the recognized laws in Indonesia, Islamic Law has an essential role in the development of national law, including Constitutional Court decisions. The authors note that there have been 20 decisions by the Constitutional Court on judicial review of laws involving Islamic Law. However, only six of these decisions used Islamic Law as the basis for consideration. The study aims to explore the construction of Islamic Law and the development of positive law in Indonesia, and to argue that efforts toward legal positivism have been ongoing, while also acknowledging the nuances of Islamic theory or Islamic Law used by Constitutional Court judges in several decisions.

Innovation

The authors do not explicitly describe their methodology in the provided abstract. However, based on the content, the study appears to be a normative legal analysis examining Constitutional Court decisions that involve Islamic Law. The analysis likely involves identifying and categorizing the 20 decisions on judicial review related to Islamic Law, and then assessing the extent to which Islamic Law was used as a basis for consideration. The authors also discuss the construction of Islamic Law and the development of positive law in Indonesia, suggesting a doctrinal approach.
Introduction
The article addresses the role of Islamic Law in enriching the legal considerations of Indonesian Constitutional Court decisions. As one of the recognized laws in Indonesia, Islamic Law has an essential role in the development of national law, including Constitutional Court decisions. The authors note that there have been 20 decisions by the Constitutional Court on judicial review of laws involving Islamic Law. However, only six of these decisions used Islamic Law as the basis for consideration. The study aims to explore the construction of Islamic Law and the development of positive law in Indonesia, and to argue that efforts toward legal positivism have been ongoing, while also acknowledging the nuances of Islamic theory or Islamic Law used by Constitutional Court judges in several decisions.

Why it matters

The authors discuss the construction of Islamic Law and the development of positive law in Indonesia. They argue that efforts toward legal positivism have been ongoing for a long time, meaning that the legal system has increasingly emphasized written law and state institutions. However, they also believe that Islamic Law has an essential role in the development of national law, as evidenced by its presence in Constitutional Court decisions. The limited number of decisions using Islamic Law as the basis (six out of 20) may reflect the secular nature of the state or the dominance of positivist legal thinking. Nevertheless, the nuances of Islamic theory in several decisions indicate that Islamic Law enriches legal considerations, even if not always explicitly acknowledged. This suggests a complex interaction between Islamic Law and positive law in Indonesia, where Islamic principles may influence judicial reasoning in subtle ways.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ