Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2022
The Roles of the Indonesian Constitutional Court in Determining State-Religion Relations
Indonesia's Constitutional Court reinforces a symbiotic state-religion relationship through judicial review, balancing Pancasila ideology with democratic rights. The Court's decisions affirm Indonesia's unique secularity model, ensuring religious diversity and national development.
Muchamad Ali Safa'atยท Constitutional Reviewยท 2022ยท DOI 10.31078/consrev815
The core problem
Indonesia is neither a religious nor a secular state. Based on the Pancasila state ideology and the 1945 Constitution, Indonesia adheres to a symbiotic model in which the state and religion are distinct entities but maintain a mutually influencing relationship. This relationship is evident in several laws regulating religious issues, particularly Islam, the majority religion. As political products, state-religion relations in law are dynamic. However, under democratic rule of law principles, these dynamics are controlled by legal instruments, notably the Constitutional Court's authority to review laws. The Court's decisions in judicial review cases related to religion reinforce the symbiotic model, affirming Pancasila as a model of Indonesian secularity that balances individual rights, religious diversity, social integration, and national development.
Innovation
The article employs a normative legal research method, analyzing Constitutional Court decisions on laws related to religion. It examines the Court's reasoning and the underlying constitutional principles, particularly Pancasila and the 1945 Constitution. The study focuses on how these decisions shape the state-religion relationship, using a qualitative analysis of case law and legal texts. The approach is descriptive-analytical, aiming to elucidate the Court's role in maintaining the symbiotic model through judicial review.
Introduction
Indonesia is neither a religious nor a secular state. Based on the Pancasila state ideology and the 1945 Constitution, Indonesia adheres to a symbiotic model in which the state and religion are distinct entities but maintain a mutually influencing relationship. This relationship is evident in several laws regulating religious issues, particularly Islam, the majority religion. As political products, state-religion relations in law are dynamic. However, under democratic rule of law principles, these dynamics are controlled by legal instruments, notably the Constitutional Court's authority to review laws. The Court's decisions in judicial review cases related to religion reinforce the symbiotic model, affirming Pancasila as a model of Indonesian secularity that balances individual rights, religious diversity, social integration, and national development.
Why it matters
The Court's jurisprudence reflects a careful navigation between religious norms and democratic principles. By reinforcing the symbiotic model, the Court ensures that state-religion relations remain dynamic yet controlled by law. This aligns with the principles of a democratic rule of law, where legal instruments mediate political dynamics. The decisions affirm Pancasila as a model of Indonesian secularity that is necessary for individual rights and freedoms, balancing religious diversity, social integration, and national development. The Court's role is thus crucial in maintaining social harmony and preventing both religious extremism and excessive secularism. The symbiotic model allows for independent development of societal domains while respecting religious values, contributing to national stability and development.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ