Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2022

The Rule of Law in the Legal Positions of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine

This article examines how the Constitutional Court of Ukraine interprets the rule of law and its constituent elements—legal certainty, proportionality, and direct action of the Constitution—through its legal positions. It highlights the role of these principles in defining the limits of human rights and the application of constitutional norms.
T. Slinko· Access to Justice in Eastern Europe· 2022· DOI 10.33327/ajee-18-5.1-n000099

The core problem

The rule of law is a foundational principle in modern constitutional democracies, and in Ukraine, both the Constitutional Court and courts of general jurisdiction play a central role in its application. This article explores the constitutionalisation of the rule of law, focusing on its constituent elements: legal certainty, proportionality, and the direct action of the Constitution. It analyses the legal positions of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (CCU) to understand how these elements are interpreted and applied. The study emphasises that the principle of proportionality is fundamental in defining the limits of human rights, requiring a balanced relationship between the purpose of restricting a right and the means used by the state. Additionally, the principle of direct action of the Constitution is noted to have limited effect, primarily concerning human and civil rights and freedoms, as well as new procedural codes. The article aims to develop theoretical and practical approaches to substantiating the nature of the rule of law and its structural elements as reflected in the CCU's jurisprudence.

Innovation

The research employs a combination of analytical and synthetic methods to examine the rule of law and its elements. Specifically, the system-structural method is used to provide a structural description of the principle of the rule of law and to analyse the content of its elements. The logical-legal method is applied to clarify the content of the legal positions of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine regarding the interpretation of the rule of law. These methods enable a comprehensive understanding of how the CCU conceptualises and applies the rule of law in its decisions.
Introduction
The rule of law is a foundational principle in modern constitutional democracies, and in Ukraine, both the Constitutional Court and courts of general jurisdiction play a central role in its application. This article explores the constitutionalisation of the rule of law, focusing on its constituent elements: legal certainty, proportionality, and the direct action of the Constitution. It analyses the legal positions of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine (CCU) to understand how these elements are interpreted and applied. The study emphasises that the principle of proportionality is fundamental in defining the limits of human rights, requiring a balanced relationship between the purpose of restricting a right and the means used by the state. Additionally, the principle of direct action of the Constitution is noted to have limited effect, primarily concerning human and civil rights and freedoms, as well as new procedural codes. The article aims to develop theoretical and practical approaches to substantiating the nature of the rule of law and its structural elements as reflected in the CCU's jurisprudence.

Why it matters

The article discusses the theoretical and practical approaches to substantiating the nature of the rule of law and the content of its structural elements as articulated by the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. It underscores that the principle of proportionality is essential for determining the boundaries of human rights, ensuring that any restriction is proportionate to the legitimate aim pursued. The limited effect of the direct action of the Constitution is analysed, noting that it primarily applies to human and civil rights and freedoms, and to new procedural codes, which are generally perceived positively. The discussion also highlights the role of the CCU in shaping the understanding of the rule of law through its legal positions, contributing to the constitutionalisation of this principle in Ukraine's legal order.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…