Pendidikan editorial
Open AccessOA2024
The Science Education Research Trends (SERT) in Indonesian Secondary Schools: A Systematic Review and Bibliometrics Study
This systematic review and bibliometric analysis of 287 papers (2000โ2020) maps the landscape of Indonesian secondary science education research, highlighting a dramatic increase in publications since 2017, a focus on critical thinking and innovative pedagogies, and the need for greater international collaboration and methodological diversity.
M. Muchson; William W. Cobern; Muhammad Saefiยท Cogent Educationยท 2024ยท DOI 10.1080/2331186X.2024.2308407
The core problem
Indonesian researchers have produced a substantial body of work on science education, yet the field lacks a comprehensive overview of its development, thematic focus, and methodological approaches. This study addresses that gap by providing an overarching sense of science education research focused on Indonesian secondary schools between 2000 and 2020. Using systematic review and bibliometric methods, the authors analyze 287 papers retrieved from Scopus to identify publication trends, leading journals, international collaborations, dominant research topics, and methodological preferences. The findings are intended to help Indonesian science educators assess their progress, identify areas for improvement, and enhance their impact on the community. Internationally, the study offers critical knowledge for global academics seeking to initiate and build networks and collaborations to advance science education worldwide.
Innovation
The study employed a systematic review combined with bibliometric analysis. A total of 287 research articles published between 2000 and 2020 were retrieved from the Scopus database, focusing on science education in Indonesian secondary schools. The bibliometric approach allowed the authors to quantify publication patterns, identify key journals, and map international collaborations. The systematic review enabled a qualitative synthesis of research topics and methods. The analysis examined publication year, journal placement, country of collaboration, research topics, and methodological orientation (quantitative vs. qualitative). No specific software or formulas are reported in the abstract; thus, the methodology is summarized as described.
Introduction
Indonesian researchers have produced a substantial body of work on science education, yet the field lacks a comprehensive overview of its development, thematic focus, and methodological approaches. This study addresses that gap by providing an overarching sense of science education research focused on Indonesian secondary schools between 2000 and 2020. Using systematic review and bibliometric methods, the authors analyze 287 papers retrieved from Scopus to identify publication trends, leading journals, international collaborations, dominant research topics, and methodological preferences. The findings are intended to help Indonesian science educators assess their progress, identify areas for improvement, and enhance their impact on the community. Internationally, the study offers critical knowledge for global academics seeking to initiate and build networks and collaborations to advance science education worldwide.
Why it matters
The findings indicate a vibrant and expanding research landscape in Indonesian secondary science education, particularly since 2017. The dominance of quantitative methods suggests a preference for measurable outcomes, which may limit deeper qualitative insights into classroom processes and contextual factors. The focus on critical thinking, problem-based learning, and HOTS aligns with global trends emphasizing 21st-century skills, yet the relatively low presence in leading international journals signals a need for greater methodological rigor and theoretical contribution. International collaborations, while present, are concentrated in specific countries; expanding these networks could enhance the visibility and impact of Indonesian research. The authors conclude that Indonesian science educators should use these findings to assess their progress and identify areas for improvement, while global academics can leverage this knowledge to foster international partnerships and advance science education globally.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ