Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2023
The Significance Of The Living Law Concept In The New Criminal Code: A Perspective Of Progressive Law
This study analyzes the importance of regulating living law in Indonesia's New Criminal Code through a progressive legal lens, finding that such provisions are necessary to safeguard legal certainty and preserve customary law continuity.
Didi Jubaidi; Khoirunnisa Khoirunnisaยท Journal of Namibian Studies: History Politics Cultureยท 2023ยท DOI 10.59670/jns.v33i.4603
The core problem
The Indonesian Criminal Code (New Criminal Code) has become a focal point of legal discourse, with the concept of "living law" (hukum yang hidup dalam masyarakat) drawing significant criticism and debate. Living law refers to the interaction between written legal norms and the dynamic developments and changes within society. This research aims to deeply analyze the significance of living law regulation in the New Criminal Code from a progressive legal perspective. The study addresses the controversy surrounding the incorporation of societal norms into formal criminal law and seeks to validate its necessity. The authors position this inquiry within the broader context of legal pluralism in Indonesia, where customary law (adat) coexists with national law. The research problem centers on whether and why living law should be explicitly regulated in the New Criminal Code, and how this aligns with progressive legal principles. By examining these questions, the study contributes to the ongoing scholarly and practical debate on the future of Indonesian criminal law.
Innovation
This research is designed using the normative juridical method, which refers to legal analysis based on existing regulations. The normative juridical approach involves examining primary legal sources such as statutes, regulations, and legal principles, as well as secondary sources including scholarly literature and legal commentary. The study focuses on the text and structure of the New Criminal Code, particularly provisions related to living law, and interprets them through the lens of progressive legal theory. The analysis is qualitative and descriptive, aiming to provide a systematic exposition of the legal norms and their underlying rationale. The authors do not employ empirical data collection; instead, they rely on doctrinal analysis to assess the coherence and implications of the living law concept within the criminal code. This method is appropriate for exploring the theoretical and normative dimensions of the legal issue at hand.
Introduction
The Indonesian Criminal Code (New Criminal Code) has become a focal point of legal discourse, with the concept of "living law" (hukum yang hidup dalam masyarakat) drawing significant criticism and debate. Living law refers to the interaction between written legal norms and the dynamic developments and changes within society. This research aims to deeply analyze the significance of living law regulation in the New Criminal Code from a progressive legal perspective. The study addresses the controversy surrounding the incorporation of societal norms into formal criminal law and seeks to validate its necessity. The authors position this inquiry within the broader context of legal pluralism in Indonesia, where customary law (adat) coexists with national law. The research problem centers on whether and why living law should be explicitly regulated in the New Criminal Code, and how this aligns with progressive legal principles. By examining these questions, the study contributes to the ongoing scholarly and practical debate on the future of Indonesian criminal law.
Why it matters
The discussion situates the findings within the broader framework of progressive legal theory. Progressive law, as advocated by scholars such as Satjipto Rahardjo, posits that law should serve human interests and be responsive to social dynamics. The incorporation of living law into the New Criminal Code reflects this progressive orientation by acknowledging that law is not static but evolves with society. The authors argue that the living law concept enhances legal certainty by formally recognizing customary law, thereby reducing conflicts between state law and community norms. This aligns with the principle of legal pluralism, where multiple legal orders coexist and interact. The analysis also addresses potential challenges, such as the risk of arbitrary application of living law and the need for clear criteria to distinguish between acceptable customary practices and those that violate human rights. The study suggests that progressive law enforcement methods, which prioritize justice and social welfare, can guide the application of living law in a manner that upholds both certainty and flexibility. The discussion concludes that the living law concept is a significant step towards a more inclusive and adaptive criminal justice system in Indonesia.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ