Pertanian & Lingkungan editorial
Open AccessOA2022
The social and ethical impacts of artificial intelligence in agriculture: mapping the agricultural AI literature
This paper maps the social and ethical impacts of AI in agriculture by thematically analyzing the literature against 11 ethical principles, identifying gaps in both agricultural AI research and AI ethics guidelines.
M. Ryanยท Ai & Societyยท 2022ยท DOI 10.1007/s00146-021-01377-9
The core problem
The paper examines the social and ethical impacts of artificial intelligence (AI) in the agricultural sector. It aims to identify prevalent challenges and impacts discussed in the literature, correlate them with the domain of AI ethics, and assess how they are being implemented into AI ethics guidelines. The research focuses on published articles and conference proceedings that address societal or ethical impacts of AI in the agri-food sector. The study employs a thematic analysis based on 11 overarching principles from an established lexicon: transparency, justice and fairness, non-maleficence, responsibility, privacy, beneficence, freedom and autonomy, trust, dignity, sustainability, and solidarity. The goal is to map the debate and illustrate what the literature says about social and ethical impacts, contrasting which impacts are not being discussed in agricultural AI and which issues are not being discussed in AI ethics guidelines but are discussed in relation to agricultural AI. This aims to identify gaps within the agricultural literature and gaps in AI ethics guidelines that may need to be addressed.
Innovation
The methodology involves a thematic analysis of published articles and conference proceedings that focus on societal or ethical impacts of AI in the agri-food sector. The analysis is structured around 11 overarching principles derived from an established lexicon: transparency, justice and fairness, non-maleficence, responsibility, privacy, beneficence, freedom and autonomy, trust, dignity, sustainability, and solidarity. The literature is examined to identify how these principles are discussed in the context of agricultural AI. The paper contrasts the impacts discussed in agricultural AI literature with those in general AI ethics guidelines, aiming to highlight discrepancies and gaps. This approach allows for a systematic mapping of the ethical landscape in agricultural AI and identifies areas that may require further attention in both research and policy.
Introduction
The paper examines the social and ethical impacts of artificial intelligence (AI) in the agricultural sector. It aims to identify prevalent challenges and impacts discussed in the literature, correlate them with the domain of AI ethics, and assess how they are being implemented into AI ethics guidelines. The research focuses on published articles and conference proceedings that address societal or ethical impacts of AI in the agri-food sector. The study employs a thematic analysis based on 11 overarching principles from an established lexicon: transparency, justice and fairness, non-maleficence, responsibility, privacy, beneficence, freedom and autonomy, trust, dignity, sustainability, and solidarity. The goal is to map the debate and illustrate what the literature says about social and ethical impacts, contrasting which impacts are not being discussed in agricultural AI and which issues are not being discussed in AI ethics guidelines but are discussed in relation to agricultural AI. This aims to identify gaps within the agricultural literature and gaps in AI ethics guidelines that may need to be addressed.
Why it matters
The discussion contrasts the impacts discussed in agricultural AI with those in AI ethics guidelines, identifying discrepancies. The paper argues that while AI agriculture research is emerging, there are gaps in the literature regarding certain ethical principles. It also points out that AI ethics guidelines may not address issues specific to agricultural AI, such as those related to sustainability and solidarity, which are particularly relevant in the agri-food sector. The analysis suggests that these gaps need to be addressed to ensure that AI in agriculture is developed and implemented in an ethically responsible manner. The paper concludes by emphasizing the importance of aligning agricultural AI research with broader AI ethics principles and calls for further research to fill these gaps.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ