Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholatโ€ฆ

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2023

The Trafficking Defence in Criminal Law: Nexus and Compulsion

This article analyses how English and Welsh courts and the CPS interpret 'compulsion' in the trafficking defence, arguing that insufficient regard to international obligations leads to breaches and re-traumatisation of victims.
S. Knightยท Journal of Criminal Lawยท 2023ยท DOI 10.1177/00220183231151920

The core problem

The United Kingdom has accepted international obligations under the Palermo Protocol, the Council of Europe Trafficking Convention, and the EU Trafficking Directive, in relation to the non-prosecution and non-punishment of victims of trafficking for offences they commit which are linked to their trafficking. These obligations are given effect through several legal mechanisms: the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) discretion not to prosecute, the abuse of process jurisdiction, the common law defence of duress, and the statutory defences under s 45 Modern Slavery Act 2015. For adult victims of trafficking, a central question arises in each case: whether they were compelled to commit the offence with which they are charged. This article demonstrates that the English and Welsh courts and the CPS have had insufficient regard to the UK's international obligations in interpreting 'compulsion', and that improvements are necessary to prevent breaches of the UK's obligations and the re-traumatisation of victims of trafficking.

Innovation

The article employs a doctrinal legal analysis, examining the relevant international instruments (Palermo Protocol, Council of Europe Trafficking Convention, EU Trafficking Directive) and their implementation in England and Wales. It critically assesses the interpretation of 'compulsion' by courts and the CPS, drawing on case law and prosecutorial guidance to evaluate compliance with international obligations. The analysis focuses on the legal frameworks providing defences for trafficking victims, including the statutory defence under s 45 Modern Slavery Act 2015, the common law defence of duress, abuse of process, and prosecutorial discretion.
Introduction
The United Kingdom has accepted international obligations under the Palermo Protocol, the Council of Europe Trafficking Convention, and the EU Trafficking Directive, in relation to the non-prosecution and non-punishment of victims of trafficking for offences they commit which are linked to their trafficking. These obligations are given effect through several legal mechanisms: the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) discretion not to prosecute, the abuse of process jurisdiction, the common law defence of duress, and the statutory defences under s 45 Modern Slavery Act 2015. For adult victims of trafficking, a central question arises in each case: whether they were compelled to commit the offence with which they are charged. This article demonstrates that the English and Welsh courts and the CPS have had insufficient regard to the UK's international obligations in interpreting 'compulsion', and that improvements are necessary to prevent breaches of the UK's obligations and the re-traumatisation of victims of trafficking.

Why it matters

The article argues that the current approach fails to adequately protect victims of trafficking, as the interpretation of 'compulsion' does not fully account for the coercive control inherent in trafficking situations. It suggests that courts and the CPS should more explicitly incorporate international obligations into their decision-making, ensuring that the non-punishment principle is effectively upheld. Improvements are necessary to align domestic practice with international commitments, thereby preventing further harm to victims and ensuring compliance with the UK's legal obligations. The discussion highlights the need for clearer guidance and training for legal practitioners to recognise the nuances of compulsion in trafficking cases.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member contentโ€ฆ