Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2024
The Use of Information and Telecommunication Networks for Criminal Purposes: Regulatory Accounting and Prospects for Expanding Criminal Law Authority
The article examines the challenges of criminal law regulation regarding the use of information and telecommunication networks for criminal purposes, critiques proposals to expand criminal law authority, and suggests amendments for a unified definition of the objective feature. It warns against repressive overreach and emphasizes the need for criminological substantiation.
N. Skripchenkoยท RUDN Journal of Lawยท 2024ยท DOI 10.22363/2313-2337-2024-28-1-196-214
The core problem
The rapid digital transformation of crime has heightened the importance of criminal law regulation. Some scholars argue that modernization is needed to ensure stricter state censure of individuals who encroach on security in the information and communication space. This article critically assesses such proposals, which would introduce numerous norms that are constructively inconsistent with the requirements of non-characteristic property of a qualifying feature for acts, potentially artificially increasing the perceived danger of crime. Instead, the author proposes amendments to ensure a unified definition of the relevant objective feature. The totality and multivariability of the use of information and telecommunication networks for criminal purposes raise the question of determining the boundaries within which the involvement of communication reserves of these technologies will form a mechanism for a criminal act. This significance has increased due to the broad interpretation by the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of the relevant objective feature in relation to the composition under paragraph "b" part 2 Article 228.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. The systematic implementation of the law may serve as a basis for a broad definition of this feature also within the framework of other compositions, posing a threat of judicial penalization of acts. The repressive nature of criminal law regulation precludes hasty reforming of the law devoid of criminological substantiation. The decision to expand the differentiating meaning of the analyzed objective feature may be dictated by the emergence in society of social relations that are not regulated by law, giving rise to acts that pose danger, or to ensure a unified normative definition of related criminal acts.
Innovation
The methodological basis of the research consists of general scientific methods (analysis and synthesis, dialectics) and specific scientific methods (criminal-statistical, systemic structural, formal legal). These methods allow for a comprehensive examination of the legal norms and their application, as well as the identification of inconsistencies and potential improvements in the criminal law regarding the use of information and telecommunication networks for criminal purposes.
Introduction
The rapid digital transformation of crime has heightened the importance of criminal law regulation. Some scholars argue that modernization is needed to ensure stricter state censure of individuals who encroach on security in the information and communication space. This article critically assesses such proposals, which would introduce numerous norms that are constructively inconsistent with the requirements of non-characteristic property of a qualifying feature for acts, potentially artificially increasing the perceived danger of crime. Instead, the author proposes amendments to ensure a unified definition of the relevant objective feature. The totality and multivariability of the use of information and telecommunication networks for criminal purposes raise the question of determining the boundaries within which the involvement of communication reserves of these technologies will form a mechanism for a criminal act. This significance has increased due to the broad interpretation by the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of the relevant objective feature in relation to the composition under paragraph "b" part 2 Article 228.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. The systematic implementation of the law may serve as a basis for a broad definition of this feature also within the framework of other compositions, posing a threat of judicial penalization of acts. The repressive nature of criminal law regulation precludes hasty reforming of the law devoid of criminological substantiation. The decision to expand the differentiating meaning of the analyzed objective feature may be dictated by the emergence in society of social relations that are not regulated by law, giving rise to acts that pose danger, or to ensure a unified normative definition of related criminal acts.
Why it matters
The discussion critically evaluates the prospects for expanding criminal law authority. The author argues that the systematic implementation of the law could lead to a broad definition of the objective feature across various compositions, threatening judicial penalization of acts. The repressive nature of criminal law regulation means that any reform must be carefully substantiated by criminological data. The decision to expand the differentiating meaning of the feature should be based on the emergence of new social relations that give rise to dangerous acts or on the need for a unified normative definition. The author proposes amendments to ensure a unified definition of the relevant objective feature, thereby avoiding the inconsistencies and potential overreach of current proposals. The analysis underscores the importance of balancing the need for effective criminal law regulation with the protection of individual rights and the avoidance of excessive penalization.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ