Ilmu Sosial editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Truth before transition: Reimagining anthropology as restorative justice
Kisha Supernant argues that anthropology must confront its colonial legacy and embrace restorative justice before it can meaningfully transition. Drawing on Indigenous critiques and her own work, she outlines a path toward an ethical, relevant discipline.
Kisha Supernant· American Anthropologist· 2024· DOI 10.1111/aman.13992
The core problem
Anthropology is at a tipping point, facing calls to 'let anthropology burn' (Jobson, 2020) and to decolonize (Gupta & Stoolman, 2022). The COVID-19 pandemic has amplified a need for collective care and a reimagining of the discipline's role in addressing climate crisis, neoliberal capitalism, and colonial violence. Supernant, a Métis woman and anthropological archaeologist, writes from her positionality and responsibilities to her relatives in Canada. She argues that any transition must begin with a reckoning with the truth of anthropology's past. Without truth, the past becomes a tether, preventing the discipline from breaking free. She acknowledges that many marginalized voices have long called for change (Deloria Jr., 1969, 1973; King, 1997; Gupta & Stoolman, 2022) and offers her perspective as one of many.
Innovation
This paper is a reflexive, positionality-driven critique and vision, not an empirical study. Supernant draws on her experience as an Indigenous archaeologist trained in four-field Americanist anthropology, her engagement with Indigenous critiques (especially Vine Deloria Jr.'s), and her work in an anthropology of restitution and restorative justice. The method is narrative and analytical, synthesizing disciplinary history, personal reflection, and calls for change. She does not claim to speak for all anthropologists or Indigenous peoples but offers a perspective grounded in her responsibilities and commitments.
Introduction
Anthropology is at a tipping point, facing calls to 'let anthropology burn' (Jobson, 2020) and to decolonize (Gupta & Stoolman, 2022). The COVID-19 pandemic has amplified a need for collective care and a reimagining of the discipline's role in addressing climate crisis, neoliberal capitalism, and colonial violence. Supernant, a Métis woman and anthropological archaeologist, writes from her positionality and responsibilities to her relatives in Canada. She argues that any transition must begin with a reckoning with the truth of anthropology's past. Without truth, the past becomes a tether, preventing the discipline from breaking free. She acknowledges that many marginalized voices have long called for change (Deloria Jr., 1969, 1973; King, 1997; Gupta & Stoolman, 2022) and offers her perspective as one of many.
Why it matters
Supernant contends that anthropology's core—cross-cultural understanding—remains valuable, but it must be reoriented. She challenges the assumption that anthropologists have the right to study others without explicit benefit to those communities. Restorative justice demands that anthropologists reckon with past harms and present responsibilities. She calls for a collective conversation about what anthropological knowledge is for and who it serves. Transition requires releasing paternalistic attitudes and embracing Indigenous self-determination. Supernant's vision is hopeful: by facing difficult truths, anthropology can become a positive force for change, helping to imagine and build futures beyond colonial and capitalist violences. She ends with a call to action: 'What you have that are relevant to the future that you might want to on a this' (Deloria, 1973, paraphrased).
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…