Pendidikan editorial
Open AccessOA2024
Unpacking Student Engagement in Higher Education Learning Analytics: A Systematic Review
This systematic review synthesizes 159 studies on learning analytics and student engagement in higher education, finding that research overwhelmingly relies on behavioral measures like clicks and task duration, while methodological reporting lacks contextual detail.
Nina Bergdahl; M. Bond; Jeanette Sjöberg; M. Dougherty; Emily Oxley· International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education· 2024· DOI 10.1186/s41239-024-00493-y
The core problem
Student engagement is critical to educational outcomes, yet it remains a complex and multifaceted concept subject to diverse interpretations. The emergence of Learning Analytics (LA) in higher education offers enhanced insight into engagement, but it is unclear how LA researchers conceptualize engagement and which dimensions and indicators are captured through log data. This systematic review addresses this gap by synthesizing primary research on LA and engagement in formal higher education settings. The authors aim to understand how engagement is conceptualized in LA studies and what aspects of engagement are measured, ultimately providing recommendations for future research and practice.
Innovation
The review followed a systematic approach, searching Web of Science, Scopus, ProQuest, A+ Education, and SAGE journals, supplemented by snowballing in OpenAlex. Studies were included if published between 2011 and 2023, were journal articles or conference papers, and explicitly focused on LA and engagement or disengagement within formal higher education. A total of 159 studies met the criteria and were extracted using EPPI Reviewer. Data extraction focused on how engagement was conceptualized, the dimensions and indicators measured, and methodological reporting quality.
Introduction
Student engagement is critical to educational outcomes, yet it remains a complex and multifaceted concept subject to diverse interpretations. The emergence of Learning Analytics (LA) in higher education offers enhanced insight into engagement, but it is unclear how LA researchers conceptualize engagement and which dimensions and indicators are captured through log data. This systematic review addresses this gap by synthesizing primary research on LA and engagement in formal higher education settings. The authors aim to understand how engagement is conceptualized in LA studies and what aspects of engagement are measured, ultimately providing recommendations for future research and practice.
Why it matters
The dominance of behavioral measures suggests that LA research may overlook important aspects of engagement, such as cognitive and emotional dimensions, which are harder to capture through log data but are crucial for understanding learning. The lack of contextual detail in reporting hinders the interpretability and generalizability of findings. The authors recommend that future research incorporate multiple dimensions of engagement, improve methodological reporting, and consider the context in which learning occurs. These recommendations aim to enhance the validity and usefulness of LA for understanding and supporting student engagement in higher education.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…