Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2022
Urgency of the Legal Structure Reformation for Law in Execution of Criminal Sanctions
This study argues that Indonesia's execution of criminal sanctions sub-system, currently under executive power, should be reformed and placed under the Supreme Court to ensure an independent, integrated, and linear criminal justice system. Using doctrinal research within a post-positivism paradigm, it identifies philosophical, sociological, and juridical grounds for urgent structural reform.
Anis Widyawati; Pujiyono Pujiyono; Nur Rochaeti; Genjie Ompoy; Nurul Natasha Binti Muhammad Zakiยท Lex Scientia Law Reviewยท 2022ยท DOI 10.15294/lesrev.v6i2.58131
The core problem
The judicial power in criminal law enforcement within the Criminal Justice System, including the execution of criminal sanctions sub-system, should be independent and self-supporting. In Indonesia, the execution of criminal sanctions sub-system is currently under the executive power, which enables the practice of execution of sanctions to be obstructed by many factors. This study addresses the urgency of revising the legal structure for criminal sanctions execution and the need for legal structure reformation for criminal enforcement in Indonesia. The research is situated within the broader criminal law system, which comprises the material criminal law sub-system, the formal criminal law sub-system, and the execution of criminal sanctions sub-system. The latter essentially acts as a sub-system of punishment. The study posits that structural reform is essential to achieve a linear, independent, synergized, and integrated system across investigative agents, prosecutors, and courts.
Innovation
The study employs a qualitative approach using doctrinal research within the post-positivism paradigm. This methodological choice allows for a normative analysis of the legal framework governing the execution of criminal sanctions in Indonesia, focusing on the structural relationships between judicial and executive powers. The doctrinal approach examines primary legal materials, including statutes and regulations, to assess the current placement of the execution sub-system and to propose reforms. The post-positivism paradigm informs an understanding of law as a social phenomenon that must be analyzed in context, considering philosophical, sociological, and juridical aspects. The research does not rely on empirical data collection but rather on a systematic interpretation of legal norms and principles to build a coherent argument for structural change.
Introduction
The judicial power in criminal law enforcement within the Criminal Justice System, including the execution of criminal sanctions sub-system, should be independent and self-supporting. In Indonesia, the execution of criminal sanctions sub-system is currently under the executive power, which enables the practice of execution of sanctions to be obstructed by many factors. This study addresses the urgency of revising the legal structure for criminal sanctions execution and the need for legal structure reformation for criminal enforcement in Indonesia. The research is situated within the broader criminal law system, which comprises the material criminal law sub-system, the formal criminal law sub-system, and the execution of criminal sanctions sub-system. The latter essentially acts as a sub-system of punishment. The study posits that structural reform is essential to achieve a linear, independent, synergized, and integrated system across investigative agents, prosecutors, and courts.
Why it matters
The analysis centers on the imperative to reform the legal structure of criminal sanctions execution in Indonesia. The study argues that the execution sub-system should be under the judicial authority, specifically the Supreme Court, to uphold the independence of judicial power in criminal law enforcement. This reform is justified on philosophical grounds (aligning with Pancasila's principles of justice and sovereignty), sociological grounds (addressing the practical obstructions in execution), and juridical grounds (ensuring consistency with the constitutional framework of judicial power). The proposed reformation aims to create a system that is linear, independent, synergized, and integrated with investigative agents, prosecutors, and courts within a single criminal law system. Such integration would enable effective supervision and coordination in the context of the integrality of punishment, falling under one protection of an integrated criminal law enforcement system. The study concludes that without structural reform, the execution of criminal sanctions will continue to face systemic barriers, undermining the overall effectiveness of the criminal justice system. The reformation is thus presented as a necessary step to achieve a coherent and unified approach to criminal law enforcement in Indonesia.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member contentโฆ