Jadwal Sholat

Memuat jadwal sholat…

Hukum editorial

Open AccessOA2026

Victim-Centric Justice in Criminal Law: A Critical Analysis of Victim Protection, Compensation and Restorative Mechanisms

This paper critically analyzes victim-centric justice in criminal law, focusing on victim protection, compensation, and restorative mechanisms within the Indian framework. It argues that despite progressive legal developments, institutional fragmentation and procedural delays hinder effective implementation.
Shambhavi Gour· International Journal of Advanced Research and Multidisciplinary Trends (IJARMT)· 2026· DOI 10.65578/ijarmt.v3.i1.641

The core problem

The traditional criminal justice system has largely operated on an offender-centric model, prioritizing prosecution and punishment while relegating victims to a peripheral and passive role. Such an approach has often resulted in inadequate protection, limited participation and insufficient redress for victims of crime. In response to these shortcomings, contemporary criminal jurisprudence has witnessed a significant shift towards victim-centric justice, which recognizes victims as rights-bearing stakeholders within the justice delivery system. This paper critically examines the concept of victim-centric justice in criminal law with specific focus on three core dimensions: victim protection, compensation and restorative justice mechanisms. It analyses the legal foundations, judicial interpretations and practical implementation of these mechanisms, particularly within the Indian criminal justice framework. The study explores how protective measures aim to prevent secondary victimization and ensure victims’ dignity and safety during criminal proceedings, while compensation and restitution seek to address the economic and psychological harm suffered by victims. The study evaluates the role of restorative justice as a complementary approach that emphasizes accountability, dialogue and social healing alongside formal adjudication. The paper argues that victim-centric justice represents a normative and ethical transformation of criminal law, aligning it with constitutional values, human rights principles and social justice objectives. Despite progressive legal developments, significant challenges persist in effective implementation due to institutional fragmentation, procedural delays and lack of awareness. The study concludes that a genuinely victim-centric justice system requires sustained institutional reform, sensitization of justice actors and integrated support mechanisms to ensure that justice is not merely punitive but also reparative and humane.

Innovation

The paper employs a doctrinal and critical analytical methodology. It examines the legal foundations, judicial interpretations, and practical implementation of victim-centric mechanisms, with a specific focus on the Indian criminal justice framework. The analysis is based on a review of statutory provisions, case law, and secondary literature on victimology and restorative justice. The study critically evaluates the three core dimensions—victim protection, compensation, and restorative justice—through the lens of constitutional values, human rights principles, and social justice objectives. The methodology involves a qualitative synthesis of legal texts and scholarly commentary to assess the gap between legal mandates and their implementation.
Introduction
The traditional criminal justice system has largely operated on an offender-centric model, prioritizing prosecution and punishment while relegating victims to a peripheral and passive role. Such an approach has often resulted in inadequate protection, limited participation and insufficient redress for victims of crime. In response to these shortcomings, contemporary criminal jurisprudence has witnessed a significant shift towards victim-centric justice, which recognizes victims as rights-bearing stakeholders within the justice delivery system. This paper critically examines the concept of victim-centric justice in criminal law with specific focus on three core dimensions: victim protection, compensation and restorative justice mechanisms. It analyses the legal foundations, judicial interpretations and practical implementation of these mechanisms, particularly within the Indian criminal justice framework. The study explores how protective measures aim to prevent secondary victimization and ensure victims’ dignity and safety during criminal proceedings, while compensation and restitution seek to address the economic and psychological harm suffered by victims. The study evaluates the role of restorative justice as a complementary approach that emphasizes accountability, dialogue and social healing alongside formal adjudication. The paper argues that victim-centric justice represents a normative and ethical transformation of criminal law, aligning it with constitutional values, human rights principles and social justice objectives. Despite progressive legal developments, significant challenges persist in effective implementation due to institutional fragmentation, procedural delays and lack of awareness. The study concludes that a genuinely victim-centric justice system requires sustained institutional reform, sensitization of justice actors and integrated support mechanisms to ensure that justice is not merely punitive but also reparative and humane.

Why it matters

The paper argues that victim-centric justice represents a normative and ethical transformation of criminal law, aligning it with constitutional values, human rights principles, and social justice objectives. The shift from an offender-centric to a victim-centric model is not merely a procedural change but a reorientation of justice delivery towards recognizing victims as rights-bearing stakeholders.

**Victim Protection**: Protective measures aim to prevent secondary victimization and ensure victims’ dignity and safety during criminal proceedings. However, the study finds that these measures are often not effectively implemented due to institutional fragmentation and lack of sensitization among justice actors. The paper suggests that sustained institutional reform and training are necessary to ensure that protective measures are consistently applied.

**Compensation and Restitution**: Compensation and restitution seek to address the economic and psychological harm suffered by victims. While legal provisions exist, procedural delays and lack of awareness often prevent victims from accessing these remedies. The paper argues for integrated support mechanisms to facilitate access to compensation and ensure timely redress.

**Restorative Justice**: Restorative justice is evaluated as a complementary approach that emphasizes accountability, dialogue, and social healing alongside formal adjudication. The study finds that restorative mechanisms are underutilized and not fully integrated into the formal justice system. The paper argues that restorative justice can enhance victim satisfaction and community healing, but requires greater institutional support and awareness.

The paper concludes that a genuinely victim-centric justice system requires sustained institutional reform, sensitization of justice actors, and integrated support mechanisms to ensure that justice is not merely punitive but also reparative and humane. The study highlights the need for a holistic approach that combines protection, compensation, and restorative justice to meet the diverse needs of victims.

Who should read this

Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.

Opening member content…