Hukum editorial
Open AccessOA2023
Virtual Emotions and Criminal Law
This digest examines the role Criminal Law should play in regulating the massive consumer use of immersive Virtual Reality (VR), proposing it as an intermediate risk scenario between physical-world crime and 2D cybercrime. It identifies three legally unaddressed risk areas—comprehensive data collection, mental reproduction of avatar experiences, and manipulation—and outlines a human-centered legal framework to define red lines.
María Isabel González-Tapia· Frontiers in Psychology· 2023· DOI 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1260425
The core problem
The article addresses the regulatory gap concerning the non-therapeutic, massive use of immersive Virtual Reality (VR) by consumers. It positions VR as an intermediate risk scenario for Criminal Law, situated between criminality entirely generated in the physical world and that developed in 2D digital environments (cybercrimes, social networks, and persuasive Artificial Intelligence). The central thesis is that VR's unique harmful potential—rooted in its capacity to evoke and modify human emotions through realistic emotional immersion—demands proactive criminal law intervention to define the red lines of massive VR use. The author argues that existing legal frameworks are insufficient and must be adapted to criminalize specific harms and risks associated with VR, adopting a democratic and human-centered approach.
Innovation
The paper employs a doctrinal legal analysis combined with a review of specialized literature from technical and legal perspectives. First, it establishes the nature of VR: from a technical standpoint, VR is characterized as a neurotechnology infused with high-risk Artificial Intelligence—an inseparable synthesis of non-invasive neurotechnology and AI systems considered high-risk for fundamental rights. From a functional perspective, VR is a "transformative" neurotechnology capable of altering what users perceive as reality, because its realism lies in emotional immersion similar to how the brain functions. Second, the paper examines reported cases and foreseeable criminality in virtual worlds or the "proto-metaverse," focusing on three specific risk areas: (1) the special comprehensive nature of data collected and stored during VR use; (2) the ability to mentally reproduce the "physical" experience of the avatar in the user; and (3) the significant capacity to manipulate individuals. These risk areas are exemplified through attacks on mental privacy, sexual freedom, and consumer manipulation. Finally, the author proposes a basic legal framework for criminalization, adapting existing laws as necessary.
Introduction
The article addresses the regulatory gap concerning the non-therapeutic, massive use of immersive Virtual Reality (VR) by consumers. It positions VR as an intermediate risk scenario for Criminal Law, situated between criminality entirely generated in the physical world and that developed in 2D digital environments (cybercrimes, social networks, and persuasive Artificial Intelligence). The central thesis is that VR's unique harmful potential—rooted in its capacity to evoke and modify human emotions through realistic emotional immersion—demands proactive criminal law intervention to define the red lines of massive VR use. The author argues that existing legal frameworks are insufficient and must be adapted to criminalize specific harms and risks associated with VR, adopting a democratic and human-centered approach.
Why it matters
The discussion centers on the need for Criminal Law to intervene promptly to define the "red lines" of massive VR use. The author argues that VR's unique characteristics—its neurotechnological nature, high-risk AI infusion, and emotional transformative capacity—justify treating it as an intermediate risk scenario requiring tailored legal responses. A democratic and human-centered approach is proposed, outlining a basic legal framework for the criminalization of specific harms and risks associated with VR. This framework would adapt existing legal categories to address the three risk areas, ensuring that mental privacy, sexual freedom, and consumer autonomy are protected. The paper concludes that without such intervention, the massive adoption of VR could lead to significant harms that fall outside current legal reach, and that proactive regulation is essential to safeguard fundamental rights in the emerging proto-metaverse.
Who should read this
Pembaca Research Digest dan praktisi rumpun ini.
Opening member content…