John Herdman Surprises with Bali Training Camp: 22 Players, Local League Dominance, and a New Name from MLS
Baca dalam 60 detik
- John Herdman memanggil 22 pemain untuk pemusatan latihan di Bali pada 9-17 November, dengan mayoritas berasal dari Liga 1 dan hanya empat pemain abroad.
- Kejutan utama datang dari pemanggilan perdana Noah Adnan (Loudoun United FC) serta peluang bagi Alta Ballah dan Taisei Marukawa yang belum resmi menjadi WNI.
- Langkah ini dinilai sebagai upaya membangun bank data pemain untuk kebutuhan jangka panjang Timnas Indonesia, termasuk sistem promosi-degradasi seperti era Garuda 1 dan Garuda 2.

Indonesia national team coach John Herdman took an unexpected step by holding a training camp (TC) in Bali on 9-17 November 2026. The decision came after the Garuda squad's international matches on the November FIFA Matchday calendar were cancelled. Herdman called up 22 players, and notably, the majority come from the domestic competition, while only four players ply their trade abroad.
The four overseas players are Mees Hilgers (Heerenveen), Adrian Wibowo (FC Wacker Innsbruck), Luke Vickery (McArthur FC), and Noah Adnan (Loudoun United FC). The last name drew attention as it is his first call-up to an Indonesia national team TC. Noah Adnan, a centre-back playing in the second tier of the MLS in the United States, immediately caught the eye of the national football public.
In addition, Herdman also gave an opportunity to Alta Ballah, the Dewa United left-back who has Liberian heritage through his father, Anthony Jommah Ballah. Alta is reportedly also called up by the Liberia national team, but Herdman wants to see him up close. Not only that, Dewa United winger Taisei Marukawa was also called up even though he has not officially taken the oath as an Indonesian citizen. Herdman appears to want to observe firsthand the quality of the player currently in the naturalization process.
Former Indonesia national team midfielder from the 1980s, Alexander Saununu, sees Herdman's decision as a surprise that is reasonable. According to him, Herdman indeed has the full right to select players, but the policy of calling up many players from the Super League (Liga 1) shows a different approach. "The decision on calling up Indonesia national team players is absolutely in John Herdman's hands. But the policy of calling up many Super League players is a surprise," Alexander said when contacted, Wednesday (11/11/2026).
Alexander suspects Herdman wants to use this TC to better understand the individual character and technical quality of each player. Although he has led matches several times, Herdman is still relatively new to Indonesia. "He wants to see Super League players up close. This is important for the Indonesia national team's data bank going forward," he explained. With a thorough understanding, Herdman is expected to find it easier to choose replacements when key players are absent.
"The Indonesia national team must have as large a player data bank as possible. We used to have Garuda 1 and Garuda 2 national teams. There was a promotion and relegation system. So every player maintained his performance to stay in the Garuda 1 national team," Alexander said.
Herdman's approach is in line with the long-term needs of the Indonesia national team. So far, the Garuda squad has often depended on a handful of overseas players, while local players have had fewer opportunities to show their quality at international level. By calling up many Liga 1 players, Herdman not only broadens the player base but also signals that performance in the domestic competition still counts.
Another surprise came from the call-up of Zanadin Fariz, the young Persik Kediri midfielder who has been impressive in the first nine matches of this season. Herdman is said to appreciate his hard work. This step shows that the English coach does not hesitate to give opportunities to young players who are consistent in the domestic league.
However, Herdman's decision also raises questions. Why is the TC held in Bali, not in Jakarta or another city with more complete facilities? It could be that Bali was chosen for weather, comfort, or a strategy to keep players away from media pressure. What is clear is that this TC is a testing ground for Herdman to shape the team composition ahead of the next tournament.
Going forward, the public will wait to see whether the players called up to the Bali TC can show their quality. If successful, Herdman's step could become a blueprint for Indonesia national team development going forward. Conversely, if it fails, criticism will point to player selection deemed unrepresentative. How will Herdman use this opportunity to build the foundation of a deeper squad? Time will tell, but the Bali TC is an interesting starting point to watch.



