Shayne Pattynama on Netizens' Fitness Test After National Team Camp, Sharp Scrutiny on Persija
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Shayne Pattynama kembali memperkuat Timnas Indonesia dalam pemusatan latihan di Bali, meski belum menembus starting XI Persija di BRI Super League.
- Unggahan Instagram-nya yang menyindir tudingan perut buncit netizen menjadi cermin tekanan publik terhadap pemain naturalisasi.
- Kembali ke Persija, Shayne menghadapi ujian sesungguhnya: menembus skuad untuk laga melawan PSM Makassar pada pekan ke-10.

Shayne Pattynama closed the Indonesia national team training camp in Bali as a player who is always grateful, but also full of questions. The defender born in Lelystad on 11 August 1998 said he was happy to return to strengthen the Garuda squad in the camp held on 9-16 November 2026, even though at club level he is still fighting for a place at Persija Jakarta.
In an Instagram post by @s.pattynama, Shayne expressed his pride at being part of the national team. “Grateful to be back for an amazing training camp in Bali! Always happy and proud to be part of this team,” he wrote. Yet behind the positive words lay a subtle jab at netizens who had highlighted his physical condition. In the post, he uploaded training photos, including a moment when his stomach was accused of being paunchy. “Hopefully I pass the netizens' fitness test,” he said, implying that he is fully aware of the public pressure that accompanies his career.
That pressure is not without reason. Shayne has indeed never played in the BRI Super League 2026/2027 with Persija. His only chance to make the squad came in the I League Cup, and even then only as a bench warmer against PSMS Medan. This situation contrasts with his role in the Indonesia national team, where he was trusted to start in a friendly against Bali United at the end of the camp. The national team coach, in this case, apparently still sees Shayne's quality as a full-back with international experience, even though his club performances have not been convincing.
The paunch controversy raised by netizens is actually not a new issue in Indonesian football. Naturalized players are often targets of harsh criticism, especially if their club performances do not meet expectations. Shayne, who has strengthened the national team since 2023, does have a good record at international level, but his lack of playing minutes at Persija has made the public question his consistency. The “netizens' fitness test” jab can be read as a clever response as well as a reflection of how great the pressure is that players must bear in the social media era.
From a tactical perspective, the national team coach's trust in Shayne shows that he is still regarded as an important asset. His ability to adapt in several positions in the back line, plus his experience playing in Europe, is an added value. However, if he continues to have few playing minutes at his club, it is not impossible that his position in the national team will be displaced by other, more regular players. Persija, as a big club with title ambitions, certainly cannot keep ignoring a player of Shayne's caliber. The Persija coach is faced with a dilemma: give him a chance or keep the existing formation.
Back at Persija, Shayne must now focus on the match against PSM Makassar at Gelora BJ Habibie Stadium, Parepare, on Saturday (21/11/2026). This week-10 match is a crucial moment for Persija to maintain momentum at the top of the table. If Shayne is given a chance, he must prove that netizens' claims about his fitness are unfounded. Conversely, if he is again left on the bench, questions about his future at the club will only grow. The public will be waiting to see whether the “netizens' fitness test” jab yields an impressive performance on the pitch, or instead backfires.
Going forward, Shayne Pattynama's career is at a crossroads. On one hand, he is still trusted by the national team; on the other, his club has not given him room. If he does not soon get regular playing minutes, it is not impossible that he will seek opportunities at another club to keep his chances of strengthening the Garuda in international competitions. Persija also needs to rethink: letting a quality naturalized player keep warming the bench is a waste of an asset. Will Shayne be able to answer the doubts with real action on the pitch, or will he sink further into the whirlpool of criticism? The answer will be seen in the coming weeks.



