Earthshot Prize to Be Held at Venue Owned by Energy Conglomerate, Environmental Activists Protest
Baca dalam 60 detik
- Upacara penghargaan Earthshot Prize 2026 akan berlangsung di Jio World Convention Centre, Mumbai, yang dimiliki Reliance Industries—korporasi di balik kilang minyak terbesar dunia.
- Kelompok konservasi menilai pemilihan lokasi itu memberi legitimasi lingkungan kepada entitas yang bisnisnya berbasis fosil dan tengah disorot soal kebun binatang Vantara.
- Tekanan publik meningkat menjelang konferensi CITES, sementara penyelenggara membela diri bahwa venue disewa dengan tarif komersial dan bukan bentuk kemitraan filantropi.

The world's most prestigious environmental award, the Earthshot Prize, will hold its annual ceremony at the Jio World Convention Centre in Mumbai on 17 November. But the choice of venue has sparked protests because it is part of Reliance Industries, the conglomerate owned by the Ambani family, which also controls the world's largest oil refinery and funds the controversial private zoo Vantara.
Reliance, through Mukesh Ambani, controls Jamnagar—the giant oil refinery in Gujarat that is the backbone of the group's fossil energy business. Its philanthropic arm funds Vantara, a 400-hectare park founded by Anant Ambani and inaugurated by Prime Minister Narendra Modi last year. Vantara houses more than 150,000 animals, including the most threatened species such as radiated tortoises from Madagascar and the Spix's macaw, which is extinct in the wild.
Megan Carr of the Wildlife Animal Protection Forum South Africa (WAPFSA) said the use of a Reliance-owned venue could give "undeserved environmental prestige" to a corporation that the global conservation community is questioning. The concern is not unfounded: Vantara has long been in the spotlight over the speed at which it collected animals and the origins of those animals.
International pressure on Vantara peaked this week. The committee of 32 countries that oversees CITES—the UN body that regulates trade in threatened species—asked India to submit a follow-up report on how it handled imports of protected animals. The committee also asked the CITES secretariat to examine 11 cases in which the origins of animal shipments to Vantara remain unclear. Previously, a CITES fact-finding mission in 2025 had recommended temporary restrictions on India, although the recommendation was later withdrawn.
Joanna Swift, Earthshot Prize's executive director of communications, denied that the organization was seeking a philanthropic partnership with Reliance. According to her, the venue was rented at a standard commercial rate because it met the technical needs of a large-scale event. "JWCC was chosen because it allows us to hold an event in Mumbai with world-class facilities," she said, adding that the venue had hosted the first Mumbai Climate Week last February.
"The Vantara model has not been proven to support conservation and could instead drive demand for wild animals in trade," said Susan Cheyne, deputy chair of the IUCN small primate section.
Cheyne highlighted the impact on gibbons and other primates. According to her, moving animals from their countries of origin to private facilities does not help wild populations without a transparent plan for welfare, conservation breeding, and return to habitat. "The real primate rescue work is done by underfunded centers in the countries of origin," she stressed.
Daniela Freyer, a co-founder of the German NGO Pro Wildlife, added that the planet is threatened by wildlife exploitation and fossil-fuel-driven climate change. "An award that aims to protect nature and improve the climate should be careful that its reputation is not dragged into this issue," she said.
Vantara denies allegations of illegal wildlife trade. On its website, it states that the goal of establishing a "modern Noah's Ark" is to save threatened animals, care for them for life, and release those that are fit for release. India's Supreme Court last year cleared the zoo of allegations of illegal acquisition and mistreatment. However, reports by the Guardian and Mongabay earlier this month revealed Vantara's efforts to lobby British officials—who chair this week's CITES meeting—to take a more sympathetic view of how animal imports were handled. Internal documents showed that ministers were advised not to interact formally with Vantara.
For Indonesia, this controversy is a mirror of how global environmental awards are increasingly being pressed to be transparent about funding sources and ties to extractive industries. A number of domestic conservation initiatives also face a similar dilemma when they receive support from corporations whose core business could harm the environment. The public is becoming more discerning in judging whether such collaborations genuinely promote sustainable practices or are merely greenwashing.
The Earthshot Prize, founded by Prince William in 2020, seeks to balance a narrative of urgency and optimism. But with CITES scrutiny yet to subside and activist protests growing, the event in Mumbai will be a test of the award's own credibility. Will this prestigious stage remain trusted as a catalyst for climate solutions, or will it be held hostage by the controversy surrounding its host partner?



